Customers consistently praised the friendly, helpful, and professional staff, highlighting their positive interactions during both sales and service experiences.
Service Quality
The service department received high marks for efficiency, thoroughness, and effective communication, with many customers appreciating the detailed video reports and timely updates.
Comfortable Environment
The waiting area was frequently noted as clean, comfortable, and well-stocked with refreshments, enhancing the overall customer experience.
Sales Experience
Many customers reported a smooth, low-pressure car buying experience, with staff being knowledgeable and accommodating throughout the process.
Mixed Feedback on Repairs
While many praised the service department, some customers expressed dissatisfaction with the inability to diagnose and resolve specific vehicle issues.
BD
Brian Delmont
4 days ago
5.0
As a longtime Outback owner, I visited Sheehy Subaru while visiting a relative in the area. I wanted to see the new new 2026 Outback "in the flesh," but was not in the market for a new car yet. Even though I explained my situation to sales manager Kara, she insisted on bringing a car around for me to see and having sales associate Godwill sit in the car with me to explain all the systems and answer my questions. I feel that my treatment was outstanding (which is all too often not the case the auto industry). So, I felt the need to share my excellent experience and recommend this Dealership.
KY
Karen Yamamoto
5 days ago
5.0
We have bought two Subbies from Sheehy. We have been impressed by their commitment to customer service. The ability to arrange a service appointment online makes servicing our vehicles easy. The videos from the service techs help us see what needs attention and I appreciate the honesty. They explain procedures well and have never charged over their quotes. We have nothing but positive things to say about Sheehy.
RV
R V
6 days ago
5.0
Walked into Sheehy Subaru Dealership in Hagerstown and the next thing you know it, I’m walking out with a brand new 2026 Outback! The whole process was so easy that I am still in disbelief that it happens so quickly! Great staff! Shout out to Kevin and to the great staff there at Sheehy Subaru in Hagerstown! Love my Subaru Outback! Great place to buy a new Subaru!
CW
C Watkins
6 days ago
5.0
I had an earlier bad experience at CMA Subaru in Winchester simply trying to get my first basic service on my Subaru. I called Sheehy and got an appointment for same day, drove an hour to Hagerstown and I was greeted, Ryan was an amazing representative of Sheehy and provided great customer service. I even spoke with Emma the Service Manager briefly and she was also an amazing representation of what Customer Service looks like and should be. I was in/out ahead of what I was told, even got a video of services being performed on my car. This place exceeded expectations and deserves 6 stars!
DM
Denny Mitts
Dec 29, 2025
5.0
***EDIT - I think this is only the second written review I've ever submitted for a business, so believe this is legitimate*** My wife and I have purchased several new and used cars over the past 25 years and never have we had such a pleasant, friendly, comfortable and time-efficient buying experience. All the staff have exhibited top-level professionalism and courtesy, as well as providing the most competitive "out the door" costs & interest rates. I'll give a particularly special thank you to Max Crocetta (worked magic with the cost numbers with a smile while thanking us for our business), Bryan Donaldson (picked me up at my house 30 minutes away...also with a smile!), Jake Moran (the best Subaru service technician!) and also Jimmy Spinnler (who is a former employee that I'm sure has moved on to share his super-freindly and positive attitude with other fortunate fellow humans! He ordered a Happy Meal for delivery to my 5 year old daughter during our purchase on September 1st - and offered us a meal as well). Thank you all, you're at the top of the game!
Frequently Asked Questions About Sheehy Subaru of Hagerstown
What are the regular business hours for Sheehy Subaru of Hagerstown?
Sheehy Subaru of Hagerstown is open from 9:00 AM to 8:00 PM Monday through Friday, and from 9:00 AM to 7:00 PM on Saturdays. The business is closed on Sundays.
Where is Sheehy Subaru of Hagerstown located?
The dealership is located at 10320 Auto Place, Hagerstown, MD 21740, United States.
Does Sheehy Subaru of Hagerstown offer vehicle service and repair?
Yes, Sheehy Subaru of Hagerstown provides automotive service and repair, including oil changes.
Is Sheehy Subaru of Hagerstown wheelchair accessible?
Yes, the dealership has a wheelchair accessible entrance to accommodate all customers.
Can customers shop in-store or order delivery at Sheehy Subaru of Hagerstown?
Customers can shop in-store and also take advantage of delivery services offered by the dealership.
What payment methods are accepted at Sheehy Subaru of Hagerstown?
The dealership accepts payments via check and debit card.
How can customers contact Sheehy Subaru of Hagerstown?
Customers can call Sheehy Subaru of Hagerstown at +1 301-760-2325 for inquiries or appointments.
Are there other automotive dealerships near Sheehy Subaru of Hagerstown?
Yes, nearby automotive dealers include Sheehy Buick GMC, Sheehy GMC of Hagerstown, Sharrett Preowned Center, Sheehy Volkswagen Hagerstown, Sheehy Mazda, and Mercedes-Benz of Hagerstown, among others.
What nearby automotive service centers could I visit after my appointment at Sheehy Subaru?
After your visit, you can consider automotive repair services at Hagerstown Honda Service, Sheehy Volkswagen of Hagerstown Service and Parts Department, Hagerstown KIA, and Toyota Sales & Service, all located near Sheehy Subaru of Hagerstown.
Are there any attractions or recreational spots near Sheehy Subaru of Hagerstown worth visiting?
Yes, visitors might enjoy nearby attractions such as MD Arsenal, a shooting range and amusement park, or explore Hendershots Sporting Goods for outdoor equipment.