Many customers praised the friendly and helpful staff, particularly highlighting the professionalism of the management team.
Service Quality
While most reviews noted excellent service and quick turnaround times, some customers reported issues with miscommunication and service execution.
Communication Issues
Several customers experienced problems with order processing and lack of timely updates, leading to frustration and dissatisfaction.
Pricing Transparency
Customers appreciated fair pricing and felt they were not pressured into unnecessary services, although some reported unexpected charges.
Mixed Experiences
While many had positive experiences, a number of reviews indicated significant issues with service quality and customer care, leading to a divide in overall satisfaction.
SS
SCB
Dec 29, 2025
5.0
Always great service. One time, I could have sworn that I needed new tires or a wheel. And these guys, it sold me straight.
It's nice to know you can have your car worked on these days and not get ripped off.
Thanks sully!!!
GR
Greg Robinson
Dec 15, 2025
5.0
The Watertown team was on top of quality service and customer experience
DS
Daria Sokolova
Dec 10, 2025
1.0
I came to Sullivan Tire on Monday asking for winter tires, and if possible, Continental Viking Contact 8 for my wheels. I was told everything would be ordered and ready, and my appointment for Wednesday at 10 AM was confirmed.
But when I arrived today for my appointment, I was told that my order was not processed for some unknown reason. The tires were not in the shop, and apparently they had been bought by someone else some time ago. No one explained why this happened, and no one notified me in advance. Instead, I got this “surprise” only when I showed up for the appointment.
If I had been told on Monday that the tires were not available, I would have immediately looked at other brands or gone to another shop and ordered a different set right away. In that case, I would have easily received them before my Friday trip to Canada. Instead, I only learned about the issue on Wednesday, after losing two full days.
I then spent the entire Wednesday driving from shop to shop, trying to find winter tires that would fit my wheels. Nothing suitable was in stock anywhere, everything had to be ordered, and the earliest delivery for the tires I needed would have been Monday, which was already too late. Sullivan Tire offered me only a couple of random tires they had in stock, but they were completely unacceptable.
Because of this situation, I ended up having to spend significantly more money on new wheels of a different size just so I could buy winter tires that were actually available in stock. All of this happened simply because Sullivan Tire acted irresponsibly and failed to communicate.
I will never return to this shop and would not recommend it to anyone, you can easily end up in the same situation.
JD
John Deighton
Nov 21, 2025
5.0
8/10
Excellent advice and service. Prompt installation. I was very impressed by Sullivan. I will make them my first call next time.
Why not a 10? Nothing to do with Sullivan. It’s the industry. So many brands, so many models, so hard to make an informed choice. I used Consumer Reports, Wirecutter and ChatGPT. None helped. I feel the industry is set up to make it inevitable that we overpay.
HM
Henry Murillo
Oct 24, 2025
5.0
The Watertown team are the best!!! Always come here for the smiles and the friendly service.
Frequently Asked Questions About Sullivan Tire & Auto Service
Where is Sullivan Tire & Auto Service located?
Sullivan Tire & Auto Service is located at 21 North Beacon Street, Watertown, MA 02472, US.
What are the regular business hours of Sullivan Tire & Auto Service?
The shop is open Monday to Friday from 7:30 AM to 6:00 PM, Saturday from 7:30 AM to 5:00 PM, and closed on Sundays.
Does Sullivan Tire & Auto Service offer tire and auto repair services?
Yes, they provide tire sales, auto repair, oil change service, and wheel alignment service.
Is it necessary to make an appointment before visiting Sullivan Tire & Auto Service?
No, appointments are not required to visit Sullivan Tire & Auto Service.
Does Sullivan Tire & Auto Service provide curbside pickup and in-store shopping options?
Yes, they offer both curbside pickup and in-store shopping options for customer convenience.
Can I find free Wi-Fi and restroom facilities at Sullivan Tire & Auto Service?
Yes, the shop provides free Wi-Fi and restroom facilities for customers.
What nearby places can I visit before or after my appointment at Sullivan Tire & Auto Service?
Nearby you can visit The Diner at 11 North Beacon for a meal, Panera Bread cafe for coffee and snacks, or explore the Watertown Founders Monument, a local landmark and antique store.
Are there nearby fitness and martial arts clubs close to Sullivan Tire & Auto Service?
Yes, Kimura BJJ USA Boston, Kimura Jiu Jitsu Academy, Boston Judo, and MacDonald Academy of Martial Arts are nearby if you're interested in martial arts or fitness classes.
Where can I get additional automotive services near Sullivan Tire & Auto Service?
O'Reilly and Son Autobody and Firestone Complete Auto Care are nearby for additional automotive repair and tire services.
How can customers in the area contact Sullivan Tire & Auto Service or find more information online?
Customers can call them at +1 617-926-5070, visit their website at www.sullivantire.com, or find them on social media platforms such as Facebook and Instagram (@sullivan_tire).