At Toy-Auto Masters, we love being the go-to auto service center for motorists all over Englewood, Colorado. For over two decades, we’ve helped Toyota, Lexus, Honda, Acura, and Subaru vehicle owners get the quality auto solutions they’ve been desperately searching for. Whatever service your vehicle needs, know that our team can provide it for you.
Many customers praised the friendly and helpful staff, highlighting their clear communication and willingness to go above and beyond for clients.
Trustworthiness
Numerous reviews emphasized the honesty and integrity of the shop, with many customers feeling confident in the assessments and recommendations provided.
Quality of Work
Overall, customers reported satisfaction with the quality of repairs and diagnostics, although there were some complaints about specific incidents of poor service.
Communication Issues
Several reviews noted problems with communication, including lack of updates on vehicle status and issues with follow-up after repairs.
Mixed Experiences
While many customers had positive experiences, there were notable negative reviews regarding accountability and service quality, indicating inconsistency in performance.
CR
Colt Rusnak
5 days ago
5.0
Jay really cares about his customers and always goes the extra mile. Nikki and Ryan at the front desk are awesome. Really great people to talk too and always make sure your service is top tier. Plus, they don't overcharge you like all the dealerships and actually build a relationship with their customers.
KK
Kaitlin Kelesoglou
Dec 22, 2025
5.0
The best, always!!!
BZ
Bryan Zerr
Dec 12, 2025
5.0
I don’t leave a lot of reviews, but I felt it was important to write one for Toy-Auto Masters.
As a small business owner myself, I believe the true mark of a great business is doing the right thing, protecting the relationship with the customer, and treating people the way you’d want to be treated—even when it means sacrificing profit.
I drive a ’22 Toyota 4Runner TRD Pro that I absolutely love, but the squeaky suspension has been a thorn in my side since I bought it. I brought it to Toy-Auto Masters after two other shops had already taken a swing at diagnosing it and missed. Right away, Ryan, the service manager, went on a drive with me and fully diagnosed the issue—something the other two shops never managed to do. A+.
Unfortunately, the Fox suspension system on this vehicle is tricky, and there was no simple fix. Ryan clearly communicated the options and possible solutions, and we went back and forth over the course of the week trying to find the best path forward. Between the complexity of the issue and my own schedule, it turned into a challenging week for both me and Ryan’s team. In the end, because of my timing constraints, I decided not to move forward with any repairs at that moment.
Here’s the part that really stood out: Ryan’s team had already put in more than a few hours of work that he refused to charge me for. Instead of insisting on full compensation for their time, Ryan and the owners of Toy-Auto chose to eat the labor cost. They absolutely did not have to do that—but they did.
Even though the squeak in my TRD Pro isn’t permanently fixed yet, I left feeling extremely grateful for the communication, thoroughness, and professionalism of Toy-Auto Masters. This is a small, family-owned shop with 30+ years of experience, and it’s obvious why they have such outstanding Google reviews (which is rare for an auto shop) and a strong reputation.
They did the right thing, and because of that, they’ve earned a lot of respect and appreciation from me.
AT
A. Murphy Tan
Dec 7, 2025
5.0
I had a great experience at Toy Auto Masters. They provided accurate diagnosis, completed the repair quickly, and offered fair, transparent pricing with clear communication throughout. Ryan, Jay, and Niki were all friendly, which made the whole process pleasant. The service felt truly trustworthy, and I would highly recommend Toy Auto Masters to anyone looking for a reliable repair shop
PT
Preston Thompson
Nov 29, 2025
1.0
Very nice people but very poor service. Damaged my vehicle and didn’t take responsibility. Will never return and have told others to stay away since that incident.