NW
Nigel Werenka
Feb 24, 2026
I brought my 2025 GMC 3500 AT4 (70,000 km, highway driven, never off-roaded) to Fountain Tire Crowfoot for one specific service: a wheel alignment.
Instead of performing the alignment, I was called and told the pitman arm was “worn out,” that the alignment could not be completed, and that it needed to be replaced at an estimated cost of approximately $1,000. I was charged a diagnostic fee and sent on my way.
Because the truck is under full extended warranty, I took it to the dealership the next day. They performed their own inspection, found no issue with the pitman arm whatsoever, charged their diagnostic fee, and completed the wheel alignment without any problem.
On top of that, while I was there strictly for an alignment, Fountain Tire also recommended a differential fluid replacement based on mileage — a service that had just recently been completed and was not part of the requested scope of work.
When I returned to discuss the incorrect diagnosis, I was told, “Well, you got your wheel alignment, didn’t you?” Yes — but only after paying $230 in combined diagnostic fees because of an assessment that the dealership could not validate.
I was later told there was “some minor play” in the pitman arm. If that’s the case, why was it presented as worn out and in need of replacement before an alignment could even be attempted? When I asked what the measured play was, I was told they would need to check with the technician. I requested a follow-up call with those measurements and never received one.
While Fountain Tire did eventually refund their own diagnostic fee, they did not cover the additional diagnostic charge from the dealership - which was only necessary due to their incorrect assessment. Nor did they account for the two days of my time spent dropping the truck off at multiple locations to resolve this situation.
Recommending a $1,000 repair on a nearly new truck - along with additional maintenance outside the requested scope - without measurable data to support it is concerning. Not every customer is mechanically inclined, and not everyone has warranty coverage. In this case, I did - and the diagnosis did not hold up under inspection.
Transparency, measurable diagnostics, and accountability matter. This experience did not reflect that.