The magic shows received high praise for being entertaining, engaging, and suitable for all ages, with many customers expressing amazement at the performances.
Food Quality
Feedback on the food was mixed, with some customers enjoying it while others found it mediocre or below expectations, particularly regarding variety and freshness.
Staff Service
The staff were frequently described as friendly, helpful, and attentive, contributing positively to the overall experience.
Atmosphere
The theater's atmosphere was noted as fun and family-friendly, enhancing the enjoyment of the shows.
Value for Money
Several reviews mentioned that the ticket prices felt high compared to the quality of food and show, with some customers feeling they did not receive good value.
MJ
Maria Jablonski
Jan 4, 2026
5.0
What a fun time! The magic, comedy, dancing and festive flare was so awesome! I always believe when people on stage are giving their all - the audience should give back their all too- this also adds to the atmosphere. Brett did a great job with his tricks- his crew were all wonderful, the staff were all so friendly and the lunch was set up nicely and our meal was delicious. We’re not talking fine dining we’re taking a super fun outing with a good meal and drinks to enjoy an afternoon or evening out. Thanks Magic & Wonder for making my mom’s 85th birthday extra special!
LL
Lee L
Jan 2, 2026
5.0
Cute show. Worth the money. Very good cast. Good magic tricks. My son loved it. We even bought one of the magic tricks for him and the cast stayed after for pictures autographs and to show how to use magic trick toys.
BH
Brei Hummer
Jan 2, 2026
4.0
Without truly knowing what to expect, I was pleasantly surprised with the show! The show was very family friendly and interactive. The magic was REAL and not cheesy!
The food was subpar but still enjoyable.
I highly recommend taking the family to Magic and Wonder Theater!
YY
Yunshan Ye
Dec 30, 2025
5.0
We (me and my wife and two daughters 16 and 21) went to the dinner and magic show and we all enjoyed it very much. It was our first time and didn’t know what to expect. Both the food and the show exceeded our expectations! Highly recommended!
KS
Kathy Statler
Dec 12, 2025
2.0
My friend & I have been to many different dinner shows in Lancaster. I must say we were very disappointed in the quality of food. Lancaster has wonderful food but this meal was very far from wonderful. The turkey & ham were great but the filling tasted like Stove Top Stuffing, the mashed potatoes tasted instant, and the corn looked like it was dumped right out off the can. The cranberry sauce was not out. I was surprised at how small the salad bar was & for only having one kind of soup let it alone was a cream soup at that.
The second half of the show was better than the first part. It was kind of mediocre & cheesy. The smoke that came off the stage was very bothersome & to people that have asthma would not have been appropriate. It was a poor quality for what we are used to to seeing in Lancaster.
I guess I’m being a “negative Nancy” but like I said I do many dinner shows a year in Lancaster & this was by far the worst.
Frequently Asked Questions About Magic & Wonder Theater
What is the Magic & Wonder Theater known for?
The Magic & Wonder Theater is TripAdvisor’s #1 Rated Attraction in Lancaster County, offering a comedy variety magic show for all ages and was awarded 2021 Best Magic and Variety Show.
Where is Magic & Wonder Theater located?
It is located at 3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562, USA.
What are the opening hours of Magic & Wonder Theater?
The theater is open Monday to Saturday from 10:00 AM to between 6:00 PM and 9:00 PM depending on the day; it is closed on Sundays.
How can I make a reservation at Magic & Wonder Theater?
Reservations can be made through their website at https://www.magicandwondershow.com/contact-variety-show.
Is Magic & Wonder Theater accessible for wheelchair users?
Yes, Magic & Wonder Theater has wheelchair accessible entrance, parking, seating, and restrooms.
Is Magic & Wonder Theater suitable for children?
Yes, the theater welcomes children and offers family-friendly shows.
What types of shows are featured at Magic & Wonder Theater?
They feature a comedy variety magic show suitable for all ages.
What nearby places can I visit when going to Magic & Wonder Theater?
Nearby you can visit the Magic & Wonder Dinner Theater, a theater, music venue, and restaurant, perfect for dining and entertainment before or after your show.
Are there nearby hotels where I can stay when visiting the Magic & Wonder Theater?
Yes, the Best Western Plus Revere Inn & Suites and Creekside Inn are nearby hotels that provide convenient accommodations for visitors.
Where can I find dining options near Magic & Wonder Theater?
Nearby dining options include Revere Tavern, Bird-in-Hand Family Restaurant & Smorgasbord, Historic Revere Tavern, Two Cousins Pizza Paradise, and Paradise View.