The magic show received high praise for its engaging performances, impressive illusions, and family-friendly atmosphere.
Staff Friendliness
Customers consistently highlighted the friendly and accommodating nature of the staff, enhancing the overall experience.
Family Involvement
Many reviews appreciated the involvement of the owner's family in the show, adding a personal touch that resonated with audiences.
Food Quality
Feedback on the food was mixed, with many customers finding it mediocre or below expectations, suggesting improvements are needed.
Value for Money
Several customers noted the affordable ticket prices relative to the quality of the show, making it a good value for family entertainment.
JB
Johnette Bennett
2 days ago
4.0
I have to say the cast and the servers could not have been nicer! There was audience participation that made the whole experience fun and entertaining. There was a variety of foods, salad bar, and dessert bar so there were options but on a buffet sometimes foods get cold or dry. The performers were talented, both in dancing and singing and the costumes were beautiful. We thoroughly enjoyed ourselves
SM
Susan Myers
4 days ago
5.0
My husband and I thoroughly enjoyed our afternoon at Magic and Wonder. The food was good, much like homemade, and the talent and costumes were exceptional. We were inspired, touched, and entertained by different scenes throughout the performances. Keep up the good work!
SD
Sharon DiMaria
5 days ago
5.0
Very entertaining. Comedy act as well as magic act. Billboard while eating has trivia information. Food was good. Family atmosphere. We are returning customers on our annual trip to Lancaster/Paradise Pa.
JW
Jen Wade
Nov 16, 2025
3.0
The act was entertaining, kind of quirky, and ridiculously overpriced for the show and dinner. The food was tasteless and bland. $84 a person, plus the cost of soda or alcohol, is too much to charge for what we received.
JV
Jen VanOrmer
Nov 12, 2025
5.0
My husband and I got tickets for the Holly Jolly Jukebox dinner and show. The cast was incredibly talented! Dinner was served buffet style, with lots of things to choose from. We had a really nice time and would definitely consider attending next year.
Frequently Asked Questions About Magic & Wonder Theater
What is the Magic & Wonder Theater known for?
The Magic & Wonder Theater is TripAdvisor’s #1 Rated Attraction in Lancaster County, offering a comedy variety magic show for all ages and was awarded 2021 Best Magic and Variety Show.
Where is Magic & Wonder Theater located?
It is located at 3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562, USA.
What are the opening hours of Magic & Wonder Theater?
The theater is open Monday to Saturday from 10:00 AM to between 6:00 PM and 9:00 PM depending on the day; it is closed on Sundays.
How can I make a reservation at Magic & Wonder Theater?
Reservations can be made through their website at https://www.magicandwondershow.com/contact-variety-show.
Is Magic & Wonder Theater accessible for wheelchair users?
Yes, Magic & Wonder Theater has wheelchair accessible entrance, parking, seating, and restrooms.
Is Magic & Wonder Theater suitable for children?
Yes, the theater welcomes children and offers family-friendly shows.
What types of shows are featured at Magic & Wonder Theater?
They feature a comedy variety magic show suitable for all ages.
What nearby places can I visit when going to Magic & Wonder Theater?
Nearby you can visit the Magic & Wonder Dinner Theater, a theater, music venue, and restaurant, perfect for dining and entertainment before or after your show.
Are there nearby hotels where I can stay when visiting the Magic & Wonder Theater?
Yes, the Best Western Plus Revere Inn & Suites and Creekside Inn are nearby hotels that provide convenient accommodations for visitors.
Where can I find dining options near Magic & Wonder Theater?
Nearby dining options include Revere Tavern, Bird-in-Hand Family Restaurant & Smorgasbord, Historic Revere Tavern, Two Cousins Pizza Paradise, and Paradise View.