For over 60 years, Colony Coin Company has been the go-to destination for collectors, investors, and hobbyists in Newton, MA. We specialize in buying and selling U.S. and world coins, rare currency, gold and silver bullion, and platinum jewelry. Our expert team provides accurate estate and insurance appraisals, helping customers understand the true value of their collections. Whether you're looking to expand your collection, sell valuable coins, or receive an expert appraisal, we are committed to offering fair prices and professional guidance. As a family-friendly business, we take pride in fostering a welcoming environment where coin collecting is celebrated across generations. Trust Colony Coin Company us for all your numismatic needs.
Wonderful, friendly manager.. I bought gold there last week and couldn’t ask for better service.
No problems, good communications.
PT
Peter Thorp
Jun 23, 2025
5.0
Harvey Fenton, is a legendary numismatist. The prices are decent and his knowledge encyclopedic. Moreover the selection is superb. All in all great!
SS
Shackleton
Mar 9, 2025
5.0
I’m here to counter any negatives - this coin shop is a treasure, and the owner operator Harvey is a wealth of knowledge. He’s salty for sure, but like any local shop experts - one must give respect to get it. My son and I went in, and there was another customer (it’s a small counter space)…so I demonstrated how to be patient and conspicuous (so as to not be seen as a theft threat)…soon it was our turn and he was great. Swapped stories. Showed us everything I requested. He’s been in business since 1970 - so if he doesn’t move fast enough for some customers, maybe get a book on Courtesy & Respect before going negative here.
SS
Shawn Summey
Sep 1, 2022
1.0
Extremely rude over the phone.
RA
Richard Antonellis
May 1, 2018
5.0
I'm 52 years old been going there since I was 5.
Sold them a coin and they sent it out and had it graded. Came back worth a lot more. When I went back in 3 months later he had an envelope with $100 in it he put aside for me. Not too many places would do that. Says a lot
For there honesty and integrity
Colony Coin Co specializes in buying and selling U.S. and world coins, rare currency, gold and silver bullion, and platinum jewelry.
Does Colony Coin Co provide appraisal services?
Yes, Colony Coin Co offers accurate estate and insurance appraisals to help customers understand the true value of their collections.
What are the operating hours of Colony Coin Co?
Colony Coin Co is open Monday from 1:00 PM to 5:30 PM, Thursday from 10:30 AM to 5:30 PM, and Saturday from 9:30 AM to 5:30 PM. It is closed on Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday, and Sunday.
Where is Colony Coin Co located?
Colony Coin Co is located at 78 Bowers, Newton, MA 02460, United States.
Does Colony Coin Co accept credit cards or only cash?
Colony Coin Co accepts only cash payments.
Is there onsite parking available at Colony Coin Co?
Yes, Colony Coin Co has onsite parking available for its customers.
How can I contact Colony Coin Co?
You can contact Colony Coin Co by calling +1 617-244-1972 or emailing haf3765@yahoo.com.
What nearby places can I visit around Colony Coin Co?
Nearby places include Marcellos Design and Builders (building supply store), Garden City Motor Parts (automotive repair), and Ansonia Wines (liquor store and convenience store). You might find it convenient to visit these locations before or after your trip to Colony Coin Co.
Are there any nearby services for pets near Colony Coin Co?
Yes, Soft Paws, a pet groomer and pet services provider, is located near Colony Coin Co, making it convenient for pet owners visiting the area.
Can visitors to Colony Coin Co find healthcare services nearby?
Yes, nearby healthcare services include Lane S. Sofman, DDS (dentist), LifeStance Therapists & Psychiatrists Newton (mental health), and Peony and the Bee Yoga (physical therapy). These services offer options for health and wellness during your visit.