Customers consistently praised the friendly, professional, and attentive service provided by the staff.
Quality of Work
Many reviews highlighted the excellent craftsmanship and quality of repairs and custom jewelry.
Pricing
While most customers found the prices reasonable, a few expressed concerns about high repair costs and low offers for selling jewelry.
Expertise
The staff's knowledge and ability to guide customers through their jewelry needs were frequently mentioned as a strong point.
Overall Experience
Overall, customers reported positive experiences, often feeling valued and appreciated during their visits.
BW
Bobby White
3 days ago
5.0
Use this jeweler for all my needs; I’ve had great experiences each time I’ve made a purchase, or repair!!
AF
Ana Fabiano
4 days ago
5.0
They are always very professional kind honest and service orientated.
AS
Anthony Sclafani
4 days ago
5.0
Great job turning a Hundred year-old ring into a pendant came out beautiful!!!
TP
Tina Putrino
Jan 2, 2026
5.0
Mr G and all the staff at East Islip Jewelers are exceptional!!! They customized my fiancee and I the most beautiful engagement rings and now they customized our wedding bands. Together they are breathtaking!!!! They also customized a beautiful necklace that has both our birthstones in an infinity symbol. They are always so accommodating and their talent is amazing!!!!
NB
Nicole Briscoe
Dec 18, 2025
5.0
I’ve used East Islip jewelers many times. They’ve made me beautiful custom pieces as well as done repairs for me. They are talented jewelers and everything is well crafted. The prices are reasonable and the work is completed quickly.
Frequently Asked Questions About East Islip Jewelers
What services does East Islip Jewelers offer?
East Islip Jewelers offers custom jewelry sales and design, buying gold and rare coins, jewelry and watch repairs, and specializes in bridal and engagement jewelry.
What are the store hours of East Islip Jewelers?
The store is open Monday and Tuesday from 10:00 AM to 5:00 PM, Wednesday from 10:00 AM to 7:00 PM, Thursday and Friday from 10:00 AM to 6:00 PM, Saturday from 10:00 AM to 3:00 PM, and closed on Sundays.
Does East Islip Jewelers offer in-store pickup or delivery?
East Islip Jewelers offers in-store pickup but does not offer delivery services.
What payment options are accepted at East Islip Jewelers?
They accept American Express, Android Pay, Apple Pay, Cash, Check, Discover, MasterCard, Samsung Pay, and Visa.
Is East Islip Jewelers wheelchair accessible?
Yes, the store has a wheelchair accessible entrance and parking.
How can customers contact East Islip Jewelers?
Customers can call the main phone number at +1 631-590-7320 or the alternate phone at +1 631-676-2932, or email sales@eastislipjewelers.com.
Which certifications and associations does East Islip Jewelers have?
They are NGC Certified, GIA Certified Diamond Retailers, members of the National Association of Professional Women, Jewelers Vigilance Committee, American Numismatic Association, and the Jeweler's Board Trade.
What notable nearby restaurants can I visit before or after shopping at East Islip Jewelers?
Nearby restaurants include Bellina's Pizza and Restaurant and Martino's Pizzeria & Restaurant, great options for a meal before or after your visit.
Are there any nearby beauty or spa services near East Islip Jewelers?
Yes, nearby beauty and spa services include Tomaso Barbershop, ELITE Nails & Beauty Spa, Andrew Stevens Salon, Vitality Spa, and Elegance Noir Beauty & Aesthetics.
What convenience stores or banks are close to East Islip Jewelers for customers' convenience?
Nearby convenience stores and banks include 7-Eleven, TD Bank, and Santander Bank ATM, which can be useful for quick errands when visiting the jewelry store.