42 Hundred On The Lake

Reviews

• YK

  Yasser Khaled

  Oct 24, 2025
  5.0
  Nicole took the time to show me different units and all the amenities. This is for sure a must see properly for any one. As the only bilingual orofacial pain specialist and realtor in Wisconsin, I would be excited to live here..
• CB

  Cortney Borchardt

  Aug 26, 2025
  5.0
  Beautiful apartments with a perfect view of the lake
• EH

  Ethan Van De Hey

  Aug 19, 2025
  3.0
  Living at 4200 can feel like a dream sometimes, but overall I’d give it a 3 out of 5 because the high rent doesn’t match the quality. The apartments feel cheaply built—walls and surfaces scratch with the lightest touch, the electronic cooktops stain and scratch easily (a nightmare since I cook with cast iron), and the Samsung dishwasher feels flimsy. The shower design is awkward, with a built-in shelf that makes it hard to move without banging elbows, and the closet layout makes it nearly impossible to close the door with clothes hanging. In the kitchen, some drawers can’t open if the fridge is open, which constantly leads to little dings while cooking. I swear the washer or dryer eats socks, though I can’t prove it yet, and the floors scratch so easily somehow even when we have protectors on everything. The hallways usually smell like wet dog or trash because of the trash chutes, and while it’s great they allow pets, barking at night, aggressive behavior in hallways, and waste everywhere drag the place down—so much so that management sends constant emails about it. On the positive side, the staff is super friendly, there’s a convenient car wash station, and the infinity pool (though now with glass barriers) is still a cool perk, even if it gets messy on holiday weekends. The mail and package rooms are secure and easy to use, and parking is free outside, but with far too few spots in winter, my wife and I had no choice but to pay $250+ monthly for underground parking, which is overpriced and doesn’t even come with a discount for couples who rent two spots. As someone in marketing, I think offering two spots for $200 would make way more sense and fill the garage, but instead, my frustration continues when the car next to me keeps dinging mine. On the bright side, the free bike system, proximity to trails, 4th of July fireworks, great views, gym, ice and coffee machines, study spaces, and grills are huge perks, and the age range of residents (lots of young couples) plus the overall safety and security make it a decent place to live. With some improvements, this complex could be 10x better, but for now, it’s a mix of awesome amenities and frustrating flaws.
• EL

  Elizabeth Long

  Feb 11, 2024
  5.0
  I have lived at 4200 on the Lake since it opened in June 2021 and many times I have thought of writing a review, and today I’m doing it because quite frankly, I am just so grateful to live here and I want to give something back. Waking up by the lake for the past (almost) three years quite literally has changed my life for the better. It’s true what they say—water brings happiness and calm and I have never slept better. Literally every day, I appreciate and have so much gratitude for my view (picture attached). My neighbors are great, some of whom have become good friends. The building is beautiful, so clean, and the amenities cannot be topped. Swimming in the infinity pool lakeside, I truly feel like I’m on vacation. But I’m at home! The gym is so clean and convenient, there are no excuses to not work out. But my biggest praise is for the office staff. I call them the Dream Team, and I am not exaggerating. Becky, Mary, and Nicole are the ultimate professionals who respond promptly to any issues that may come up in this business of life. I feel so safe knowing that they are taking care of this building. When they say they care about their residents, they mean it! Because their actions prove it. I highly recommend 4200 to anyone looking for a wonderful place to live!

Frequently Asked Questions About 42 Hundred On The Lake