At the Sean McCarthy State Farm Agency, our mission is to be your first choice for insurance by fostering personal relationships and empowering you to understand the everyday risks you face. We are dedicated to providing comprehensive coverage options, including Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Condo Insurance, Renters Insurance, Life Insurance, and Business/Commercial Insurance, personalized to meet the needs of our customers throughout Long Island and the boroughs of New York City.
Through our commitment to exceptional service and a clear vision for the future, we strive to create a community where our customers feel informed, secure, and supported in their insurance decisions. Your equanimity is our priority, and we are here to guide you every step of the way.
Marian Cotter is an amazing agent. I’ve actually been using this agency, firstly for home owners insurance since 2014. Tomorrow, I’ll be purchasing a new vehicle! Marian was so knowledgeable and professional when explaining the auto insurance process. She is a genuine, honest and caring individual, who listened to me and my daughter. She answered all our questions. Marian truly is an asset to Sean McCarthy-State Farm Insurance!
MA
Minalou Allen
Dec 4, 2025
5.0
I have been working with Deann in Sean Mcarthy State Farm Insurance since I was single until got married we have 2 kids and they are grown up already and still with this . Co because Deann is always good with the customer very pleasant, helpful, reliable , , happy all the time to answer any questions when you call for questions always have an answer and good suggestion always trying to save you money, I’m with this co for 2 decades already for auto insurance and then bought a house of course we called Deann for homeowner insurance you will build a friendship relationship that’s how happy we are with Deann Thank you so much Deann always nice talking to you !!
JA
John Alleyne
Nov 13, 2025
5.0
Mirian is great, she can always be relied on for and she’s always polite and positive. I’ve been using her for over 10 years
LD
lisa dieken
Oct 29, 2025
5.0
DEANN is absolutely the very best in the business. I have dealt with her for several years now and all i can say is Sean McCarthy Agency is blessed to have her. Deann is diligent, courteous, friendly and most importantly knowledgeable. If I did not have Deann as my insurance agent I do not know what I would do. She takes a daunting task and takes all the stress out of it. I will never go elsewhere for my insurance needs and neither should you. Thank you Deann for once again assisting me and making the process smooth and stress free.
KK
K K
Oct 8, 2025
5.0
DEANN is a rockstar!!! Honestly, I have been with State Farm for years. Auto, homeowners, umbrella insurance. And yes, when that bill comes around, it's always hard to part with your hard earned money. But recently, my son was in an auto accident. And I am not sure how I could have navigated this entire process without Deann's guidance. Rockstar? Guru? Yes and yes. Give that woman a raise and promotion because dealing with a client like me isn't easy. If you call them to get a quote, ask for Deann :)
Frequently Asked Questions About Sean McCarthy - State Farm Insurance Agent
What types of insurance does Sean McCarthy - State Farm Insurance Agent offer?
They provide Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Condo Insurance, Renters Insurance, Life Insurance, and Business/Commercial Insurance tailored to customer needs.
Where is Sean McCarthy - State Farm Insurance Agent located?
The agency is located at 1100 Stewart Ave, Ste 3, Garden City, NY 11530.
What are the regular office hours for the Sean McCarthy State Farm agency?
Office hours are Monday to Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM; the agency is closed on Saturdays and Sundays.
Is customer service available outside of regular business hours?
Yes, customer service is available 24/7 online.
Does Sean McCarthy - State Farm Insurance Agent offer services in languages other than English?
Yes, the team is bilingual and offers services in Spanish and Portuguese.
What payment methods are accepted at Sean McCarthy State Farm Agency?
They accept American Express, Cash, Check, Diners Club, Discover, Mastercard, and Visa.
Does the agency have wheelchair accessible facilities?
Yes, the agency has wheelchair accessible entrances, parking, seating, and restrooms.
Can I get an insurance quote online at Sean McCarthy - State Farm Insurance Agent?
Yes, you can obtain a free insurance quote online at https://www.sfmccarthy.com/quote.
What nearby places can I visit around the Sean McCarthy State Farm Agency?
Nearby you can visit Eisenhauer Park for outdoor activities, DJ's International Buffet for a meal, or The Polo Cigar Lounge for a relaxing lounge experience.
How can nearby transit or services help me visit Sean McCarthy State Farm in Garden City?
Local amenities like the arcade at Waypoint Gaming or fitness activities at Dynamix Cycle & Pilates provide good landmarks when visiting the agency, which is easily accessible in the Garden City area.