Foster & Witmer Inc

Reviews

• NH

  Nick Hess

  1 day ago
  5.0
  I've worked with Foster and Witmer for nearly 30 years - they've worked hard for me and have kept me out of trouble. Solid recommend!
• KD

  Kenneth Densmore

  Nov 10, 2025
  1.0
  Disappointing Experience, Great Promises But No Follow-Through I don’t normally write negative reviews, but after the amount of time and money lost trying to work with Foster & Whitman through Cappi, I feel it’s important to share our experience. After reading all the positive reviews, we reached out to Foster & Whitman on August 20th, 2025. As of November 10th, 2025, we still haven’t received a single quote or follow-up with actual insurance options. Call 1: Our first conversation with Cappi went great. Friendly, confident, and professional. We were told, “You’ll hear from us next week.” Two weeks later: No contact, so I called back. I was told they had been busy with Memorial Day weekend but had met with some new contacts that would help move things forward. “You’ll hear from us in a week or sooner,” they said. Another two weeks later: Still nothing. I called again and was told, “We haven’t forgotten about you, we’re almost there, I’ve been working on it, my bad for the delay, you’ll definitely hear from us soon.” That was three weeks ago, and we’ve never heard back since. While I understand that insurance prices have gone up and delays can happen, communication matters. We trusted the many great reviews and genuinely believed this team would deliver. Instead, we’ve ended up weeks behind, missing valuable time and opportunities to find coverage elsewhere, all while hearing repeated apologies and reassurances but no real action. I wish our experience matched what others described, but unfortunately, it’s been nothing but lost time and frustration.
• AR

  Ameea Robinson

  Nov 6, 2025
  5.0
  Ms. Wendy is courteous and got quotes for me quickly and kept me abreast of any changes.
• JA

  J. M. Dominguez (ASAPTKS)

  Oct 23, 2025
  5.0
  As always, I expected nothing less from the staff at this office and from Rod Witmer, who has provided excellent service for many years.
• NB

  Nakiah Bodley

  Oct 23, 2025
  5.0
  Ms. Kathy is the G.O.A.T! She made what seemed like a difficult issue an absolute breeze. I would definitely recommend Ms. Kathy and her team they are professional, friendly, and extremely knowledgeable.

Frequently Asked Questions About Foster & Witmer Inc