Fred Trelli - GEICO Insurance Agent

4.4
488 reviews

About

Insurance Agency
Serving the insurance needs of Fort Myers. Your Local GEICO agent could help you save on auto, motorcycle, renters insurance, and more. Contact us today to start an insurance quote! Please call or email your local GEICO Office to learn more as office hours may vary.

Location

Fred Trelli - GEICO Insurance Agent
12123 South Cleveland Avenue, Fort Myers, FL
33907, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.4
488 reviews
5 stars
395
4 stars
20
3 stars
12
2 stars
13
1 star
48
  • GS
    Greg Simons
    4 days ago
    1.0
    Shockingly bad customer service. I've had geico auto policy for several years and due to a clerical mixup on their end geico auto-canceled my policy. I've been trying to reach their corporate office for over a week to restart the policy. The hold times are endless. I called this agency this morning hoping a local resource would be faster and more accessible. The woman who answered the phone acknowledged my problem with apathy and said she would get someone to help. She then immediately transferred me to the same corporate line that no one ever answers. I'm trying to give geico and this insurance agent money and they're too incompetent to accept it. Truly astounding. Get your insurance anywhere else.
  • CM
    Charles Miscioscio
    Nov 14, 2025
    5.0
    Very friendly and professional with great rates for auto insurance.
  • CS
    Cathy Smith
    Oct 22, 2025
    4.0
    I compared prices on auto insurance and the rates are really good! It's a reputable company...and many people in my park recommended it! After reviewing my coverage....uninsured motorist was left off...this raises the amount you pay! Check your coverage before you leave the store!
  • LG
    Lee Gonthier
    Sep 8, 2025
    5.0
    Onil is courteous and knowledgeable. Good service!
  • JS
    Jason S
    Sep 2, 2025
    2.0
    Bait and switch. GEICO offered me a lowball rate online, then when I went to sign up, suddenly all these other things increased my rates. I selected uninsured motorist coverage online, but I was told it was not selected when they quoted me, and they had to add a couple hundred more dollars. Additionally, I was penalized for glass claims which are free in the state of Florida. So basically, they offer you a low rate, they come up with a bunch of excuses to double the rate and it turns out it’s actually more expensive than my insurance. I’m just glad I found out before I signed up… seems like they really need to get it together here at GEICO.

Frequently Asked Questions About Fred Trelli - GEICO Insurance Agent

What types of insurance does Fred Trelli - GEICO Insurance Agent offer?

Fred Trelli offers Auto, Motorcycle, Homeowners, Boat, and Renters Insurance.

Where is Fred Trelli - GEICO Insurance Agent located?

The office is located at 12123 South Cleveland Avenue, Fort Myers, FL 33907, US.