As your Fernandina Beach insurance experts, we can provide you with multiple quotes from a variety of insurance companies to help you find the best coverage at the best price. Contact us at (904) 491-7622 or visit us online at https://www.brightway.com/agencies/FL/Fernandina-Beach/0042 today for a customized quote!
As a mortgage lender, I work with a lot of insurance providers, and Brightway the Tarzia Agency is truly one of the best. Their customer service is exceptional, and their entire team is responsive, professional, and always willing to go the extra mile for clients.
Mike Tarzia has built an outstanding team, and it shows in every interaction. They make the insurance process smooth and stress-free, which makes my job easier and provides real value to the homebuyers I work with.
Highly recommend the Tarzia Agency to anyone looking for a reliable, customer-focused insurance partner!
AA
Andy Au
5 days ago
5.0
I’ve worked with Mike and Angela for home/car insurance and everytime they have excelled in their ability to execute. It’s never a fun time when you’re told you have to look for insurance of any kind but at least with these two leading the way you’ll know you’ll have amazing, honest and reliable service to make it that much more bearable.
AM
Amanda Murphy
Nov 12, 2025
5.0
Brightway is great to work with for your insurance needs. Personally Henry Pertkiewicz I’d the best! Very responsive, even after hours. He helped me save over $1000 on my 6 month premium. He shopped insurance for me before renewal without me having to ask. Highly recommend!!
KE
Ken Ernst
Nov 12, 2025
5.0
My agent at Brightway Insurance Henry Perkiewicz handled getting our car insurance. They also handle our Home insurance. When ever l have a question about our policies he is right there with the answer. Also in the past we have had an insurance company raise their rates quite high over night and quickly Henry searched to find a better company with better rate. We are very happy with him.
MF
Mary Fox
Nov 12, 2025
5.0
Henry at Brightway was fantastic. He was extremely efficient and was never too busy to answer any questions I had. I appreciated his attention to detail and look forward to many more years with him.
Frequently Asked Questions About Brightway Insurance, The Tarzia Agency
What are the regular business hours for Brightway Insurance, The Tarzia Agency?
The agency is open Monday through Friday from 8:30 AM to 5:00 PM, and is closed on Saturdays and Sundays.
Can I schedule an appointment on weekends at The Tarzia Agency?
Yes, appointments are available on Saturday and Sunday by appointment only.
What types of insurance services does The Tarzia Agency offer?
They offer a variety of insurance services including umbrella, motorcycle, renters, auto, home, flood, boat, RV, ATV, and classic car insurance.
How can I contact Brightway Insurance, The Tarzia Agency?
You can call them at (904) 491-7622 or email mike.tarzia@brightway.com for inquiries and quotes.
Where is Brightway Insurance, The Tarzia Agency located?
The agency is located at 960185 Gateway Blvd., Unit 107, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034.
Does Brightway Insurance, The Tarzia Agency have an online presence where I can get a quote?
Yes, you can visit their website at https://www.brightway.com/agencies/FL/Fernandina-Beach/0042 to get a personalized insurance quote.
Are there any coffee shops near The Tarzia Agency where I can grab a drink before my appointment?
Yes, Holy Grounds Coffee House and Espressos Cafe are nearby coffee shops where you can enjoy a drink before your visit.
What nearby services might be useful when visiting Brightway Insurance, The Tarzia Agency?
Nearby you can find The Paradise Team for real estate needs and Landmark Title for real estate services, which could be helpful if you're purchasing property and need insurance.
Is there access to public transportation near The Tarzia Agency?
Yes, the Florida Times Union train station and broadcasting media location is nearby, which could help you reach the agency via public transit.
Are there other insurance agencies close to Brightway Insurance, The Tarzia Agency?
Yes, Julia Strong- Brightway Insurance Fernandina Beach and Timothy “Insurance Dude” Yarbrough insurance agencies are located nearby.