Home Insurance AgencyAuto Insurance AgencyInsurance Agency
As your Fernandina Beach insurance experts, we can provide you with multiple quotes from a variety of insurance companies to help you find the best coverage at the best price. Contact us at (904) 712-6300 or visit us online at https://brightway.com/agencies/fl/fernandina-beach/0244 today for a customized quote!
Lauren Mathewson and Callie Wilder are great to work with. They were able to get our new policy in place with no delays and made extra calls and emails to all the involved parties.
MP
Michael Pigage
6 days ago
5.0
The Brightway staff (Callie) was prompt, professional and courteous.
MW
Melissa W
Nov 14, 2025
5.0
Callie made the process of getting home insurance for my new house easy. She was very professional in answering all my questions and concerns and took the time to walk me through the process. Callie found a great policy at an affordable price and worked with my lender to coordinate all the needed documentation; taking me one step closer to owning my own home. I highly recommend contacting Brightway when searching for insurance.
CP
Charlie Perry
Nov 9, 2025
5.0
The folks at Brightway are incredibly helpful. Jackson S. helped me on my home insurance and flood insurance, and was incredibly pleasant to work with.
NH
Nancy Haas-Dodd
Oct 24, 2025
5.0
Callie made the whole process of choosing homeowners insurance easy and thought through. She explained all the options to me and gave me the tools to decide what coverage was best for me. She communicates effectively and timely. But everyone at Brightways that I had contact with were professional and proactive in working with me. Here’s to a long term relationship!
Frequently Asked Questions About Brightway Insurance, The Coastal Agency
What types of insurance does Brightway Insurance, The Coastal Agency offer?
They offer multiple insurance options including home, auto, and other property and casualty insurance through various brands.
Where is Brightway Insurance, The Coastal Agency located?
It is located at 5472 1st Coast Highway, Ste 12, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034, USA.
What are the business hours of Brightway Insurance, The Coastal Agency?
They are open Monday through Friday from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM and closed on weekends.
Is it necessary to make an appointment to visit Brightway Insurance, The Coastal Agency?
Appointments are encouraged to ensure timely service.
How can I contact Brightway Insurance, The Coastal Agency?
You can reach them by phone at (904) 712-6300 or by email at coastalagency@brightway.com.
What geographic areas does Brightway Insurance, The Coastal Agency serve?
They serve areas including Nassau County, Jacksonville, Camden County (GA), Fernandina Beach, Kingsland, and several other nearby locations in Florida and Georgia.
Are there restaurants near Brightway Insurance, The Coastal Agency where I can dine before or after my visit?
Yes, nearby restaurants include Horizons, Gennaro's Italiano South, KP's, Pogo's Kitchen, and GG's Bistro, offering various dining options.
I am staying at the Ritz Carlton. How easy is it to get to Brightway Insurance, The Coastal Agency from there?
The Brightway Insurance agency is close to the Ritz Carlton, making it convenient for guests to visit for insurance needs during their stay.
What nearby services can I visit alongside Brightway Insurance, The Coastal Agency?
Nearby services include Coastal Living Title for real estate, Making Waves Amelia for beauty services, and Amelia Island Rentals for accommodations.
Are there any recreational spots near Brightway Insurance, The Coastal Agency?
Yes, South End Beach and The Golf Club of Amelia Island are nearby spots perfect for relaxation or leisure before or after your visit.