Business Details
About
Pizza Restaurant
Il Nonno Pizza brings the taste of Italy to Falling Waters, WV with
handcrafted, pizzas made from fresh, quality ingredients. Familyowned and proudly local, we offer a cozy atmosphere, fast takeout,
and friendly service. From classic Margherita to creative house
specials, every slice is made with tradition and love. Stop by and
see why we’re a local favorite
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.6
150 reviews
5 stars
122
4 stars
10
3 stars
10
2 stars1
1 star
7
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Customers have mixed opinions on the food quality, with some praising the pizza and others finding it average or not authentic.
Service
The staff is frequently described as friendly and attentive, contributing positively to the overall customer experience.
Cleanliness
The restaurant is noted for its cleanliness, with many customers appreciating the tidy atmosphere.
Value
While some customers find the prices reasonable for the portion sizes, others feel certain items are overpriced for the quality.
Customer Experience
Overall, many reviews highlight a welcoming atmosphere and positive interactions with the owners and staff.
- GTGypsy ThorpeOct 18, 20251.0The owner and his daughter are sweet and kind people but the food, just wasn’t to my taste. I loved the restaurant and the people but personally if someone wanted pizza I would tell them to go to Kings Pizza
- JNJim NapierOct 14, 20255.0Very good tasting pizza. Large sizes for the price.
- ASAndrew SchmidtSep 20, 20255.0We had takeout and it was delicious
- JBJohn BSep 7, 20252.0This is NOT authentic Italian. Sauce was bland, pizza had hardly any sauce, jarred mushrooms, and was 90% cheese. Service was very good, but the food average at best. Angelo’s in Martinsburg is much better.
- JCJasmine CaballeroAug 9, 20255.0I haven’t been home to NY in years, and living in Maryland, it’s been nearly impossible to find a pizzeria that truly knows how to make authentic NY pizza — that perfect balance of flavor with a thin, crunchy crust. But Il Nonno Pizza absolutely nailed it! 🍕 From the very first bite, I felt like I was back in New York. The crust has that signature crunch without being overdone, the sauce is rich and flavorful, and the cheese is perfectly melted with just the right stretch. They truly know what they’re doing here! Beyond the incredible pizza, the atmosphere is spotless — you can tell they take pride in keeping their space clean and welcoming. The customer service is exceptional; every staff member I’ve interacted with has been friendly, attentive, and genuinely happy to be there. If you’re searching for the real deal NY-style pizza in Maryland, look no further — Il Nonno Pizza is hands-down the best! I’m so glad I found them, and I’ll definitely be back again and again.
Frequently Asked Questions About IL Nonno Pizza
Where is IL Nonno Pizza located?
IL Nonno Pizza is located at 9460 Williamsport Pike, Falling Waters, WV 25419, USA.
What types of food does IL Nonno Pizza serve?
IL Nonno Pizza serves handcrafted Italian food including pizza, hot and cold subs, steak and cheese, pasta, and stromboli.
What are the opening hours of IL Nonno Pizza?
IL Nonno Pizza is open Monday to Thursday from 10:30 AM to 9:30 PM, Friday from 10:30 AM to 10:30 PM, and Saturday and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM.
Is IL Nonno Pizza family-owned and locally operated?
Yes, IL Nonno Pizza is family-owned and proudly local, offering a cozy atmosphere and friendly service.
Can I order food online from IL Nonno Pizza?
Yes, you can order online at https://ilnonnopizza.com/.
What is the contact number for IL Nonno Pizza?
You can contact IL Nonno Pizza at +1 304-989-0101.
What nearby restaurants are close to IL Nonno Pizza?
Nearby restaurants include Ovidio's New York Pizza and Sandstone Corner, great options if you want more pizza variety or a bar experience in the area.
Are there any nearby services to visit before or after dining at IL Nonno Pizza?
Yes, after your visit to IL Nonno Pizza, you can stop by Paul Doberman Kennel for pet services or A&D Custom Furniture if you are interested in local shops.
What community or religious organizations are near IL Nonno Pizza?
Harmony United Methodist Church and Marlowe Assembly of God Church are nearby, which can be convenient for visitors attending services or community events.
Is there a library nearby IL Nonno Pizza where I can spend time with family or friends?
Yes, the North Berkeley Public Library is nearby and is a great place to visit for reading or community events before or after enjoying a meal at IL Nonno Pizza.