Business Details
About
Pizza RestaurantRestaurant Delivery ServiceCatererGlass Nickel Pizza
We’re a locally-owned pizza place offering fresh pizzas, wings, subs, salads, and more right here in Menasha -- join us for a slice soon!
Details
- Dine-inNot available
- DeliveryAvailable
- TakeoutAvailable
- Credit cardAvailable
Location
Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Menasha-Neenah
217 Washington St., Menasha, WI
54952, United States
Hours
Reviews
4.1
221 reviews
5 stars
136
4 stars
33
3 stars
15
2 stars
12
1 star
25
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Mixed reviews on food quality; some customers praised the pizza while others reported issues with toppings, temperature, and overall taste.
Customer Service
Customer service experiences vary widely; some customers reported friendly and accommodating staff, while others faced issues with order accuracy and responsiveness.
Delivery Issues
Delivery times and order accuracy are frequent complaints, with several customers noting delays and incorrect orders.
Cleanliness
The restaurant is noted for its cleanliness, which positively impacts customer perceptions of food safety.
Pricing
Many customers feel the prices are high relative to the quality and quantity of food received.
- GPGenevieve PellDec 19, 20254.0Moving from Madison 11yrs ago, we were thrilled when Glass Nickel opened in Appleton. Awesome food. Always delicious.
- DWDaniel WahlstrandDec 12, 20251.0Refused service because they couldn't change my address on file. Ok then!
- PPPATRICKNov 22, 20251.0Food sucked big time. They lost me as a customer!
- RRRyan RotheOct 27, 20253.0Ordered a medium cheese, large cordon bleu and nickel nuggets for delivery. With tip came to almost 65 bucks. Pizza was lukewarm, cordon bleu pizza had no ham. Called and got a credit for our next order but for what we paid and the quality of food I don’t know the next time we’d order again.
- BKBob KohlsOct 15, 20253.0It would have been nice if whoever cut the pizza would have cut it instead of making dents in the pizza. We had to recut.
Frequently Asked Questions About Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Menasha-Neenah
What types of food does Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Menasha-Neenah offer?
Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Menasha-Neenah offers fresh pizzas, wings, subs, salads, pasta, and more, including vegetarian and vegan options.
Does Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Menasha-Neenah accept reservations?
No, Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Menasha-Neenah does not accept reservations.
What are the operating hours of Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Menasha-Neenah?
They are open Monday to Thursday and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, and Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM.
Are there any days Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Menasha-Neenah is closed for holidays?
Yes, the restaurant is closed on November 27, December 24, and December 25 in 2025.
What pickup and delivery services does Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Menasha-Neenah offer?
They offer in-store pickup, curbside pickup, delivery, same-day delivery, and no-contact delivery.
What payment options are accepted at Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Menasha-Neenah?
They accept American Express, Cash, Discover, MasterCard, and Visa.
How can I place an online order from Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Menasha-Neenah?
You can place an order online at https://order.glassnickelpizza.com/.
Where is Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Menasha-Neenah located?
It is located at 217 Washington St., Menasha, WI 54952, USA, in the Neenah-Menasha neighborhood.
What nearby places can I visit before or after dining at Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Menasha-Neenah?
Nearby places include Mercy Tree Salon for beauty services, The Restoration furniture store and IT services, and Double Portion Soup Kitchen for a community breakfast or brunch experience.
Are there nearby pizza restaurants around Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Menasha-Neenah?
Yes, nearby pizza dining options include Luigi's Pizza & Pasta and LuigisOnTheGo food truck, which offer Italian-style meals.