Mr Gatti's Pizza

Reviews

• KW

  Kenneth Wood

  Jan 19, 2026
  4.0
  I purchased a personal pan pizza and I felt like they put to much sauce for a pizza that size.
• FA

  Fran Allen

  Dec 26, 2025
  2.0
  Edited review 1/8/26.....I was asked to email marketing after the owner read my review (I emailed thwm right away). No response so far! 12/26/25....My husband and I come and get pizza here every Friday night since they opened. We have never had any issues that they didn't fix for us until tonight. When I picked up my order I was told they had no medium boxes and no large boxes so my medium pizzas got shoved into small pizza boxes. Pizza slices are flipped over and stuck to each other. No apologies were given. We did get some discount coupons from the district manager 3 weeks ago and we appreciate that but y'all need to do better! Disappointed tonight!
• RN

  Richard Nichols

  Dec 2, 2025
  1.0
  Horrible pizza for the money. Crust was cardboard, toppings minimal. A Digiorno bake at home would be 10 times better. This place advertises best pizza in town. Keep driving. We didn't even feed it to the dog. Not worth it at all. Zero stars for this place and I am generally not picky. But I feel I got my pocket picked!
• PS

  Piper Segroves

  Apr 18, 2025
  5.0
  This pizza is so good! It isn't too greasy and it wasn't soggy at all. Brayden helped me and was so nice. I got the personal pizza combo, and I didn't wait long for my meal.
• JS

  Jacob Smith

  Apr 8, 2025
  1.0
  Extremely slow.