Built inside a 1929 mansion that presumably once was financed by Al Capone, the restaurant serves a menu of traditional gourmet dishes including Brie en Croute, Blackened Salmon Oscar and Black Thai Duck. The mansion that houses the restaurant was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1997 and still features the original escape hatches and underground tunnels that were used by Capone to transfer liquor during the Prohibition Era. In 2001, High Point received the "Best Gourmet Meal in Tennessee" award from "Tennessee" magazine.
Overall, the food received mixed reviews; while many praised specific dishes like the lobster bisque and steaks, others found certain items underwhelming or overpriced.
Service
Service quality varied significantly; some customers highlighted attentive and friendly staff, while others experienced slow service and issues with order accuracy.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's unique historical setting and ambiance were frequently praised, making it a popular choice for special occasions.
Pricing
Many customers noted that while the food and experience were enjoyable, the prices were high, leading to expectations for exceptional quality and service.
RK
Robert K
Dec 31, 2025
5.0
Celebrated my 50th birthday at High Point. Food was amazing steak so tender you could cut it with a fork awesome atmosphere and vibe will definitely be back. I had the ribeye absolutely amazing. Had the BLT salad. It was almost a meal in itself.
PL
Paul Loeffel
Dec 19, 2025
5.0
Wonderful restaurant for a special occasion. Service was spot on and very attentive. Food was top quality, expertly prepared and seasoned to perfection. Note the reservations are required.
JB
Julie Byers
Dec 9, 2025
4.0
I had read about Highpoint in a magazine. I like the concept. It was fine dining with a dress up atmosphere in an old mansion.
I made reservations months ago. That was an easy process, but you have to call. There are no confirmations from the first phone call until you show up for your meal. please make sure you note the time and date of your reservation. We had so it was no problem just making a note.
It was a cold rainy night when we showed up. I was dressed in a fine dress and my husband in a suit. we were definitely overdressed. Per the newspaper or magazine article. It indicated that that was the preferred dress. Per their website, it indicated they preferred dressy attire. Most of the gentlemen were in jeans and cowboy boots. I think I was the only woman in dress.
The food was very good. The service was nice. Our server had a little bit of spunk to her, which was cute.
The house, which belonged to Al Capone’s mistress, was decorated very nice for the holidays. We had a cute table for two by the windows. It was a very romantic setting.
If you’re in the area or want an overnight escape, I would definitely eat here.
MM
m morgan
Dec 2, 2025
5.0
Friends invited me for my first time here. Great reputation for elegant dining at "Capones hangout" and it was excellent. So many choices of delicious entrees and many are unique to this restaurant. Prices are a little higher but this is a wonderful outing and well worth it for the quality. Add this gem to your bucket list and make a reservation.
RM
Rebecca McCoin
Nov 30, 2025
4.0
Don’t go here for the food. We eat out A LOT and travel all over the south. We we underwhelmed with everything. The rolls were hard and difficult to chew. The ribeye was a tad overdone, maybe because it was pretty thin? The baked potato and salad were okay. They let my picky husband order fried chicken tenders, which weren’t on the menu and we thought that was great. The tenders were juicy but didn’t have much flavor. I did think the drinks were pretty good. Overall we thought it was a cute little place to experience once but for the price the food should knock purple socks off. You are paying almost double here for the ambiance only in my opinion. There was a nice waitress that caught us dancing after we ate and took some pictures for us. We did not get the name of our waitress because she didn’t give it to us. We won’t be back because of the food and prices but glad we got to try it!
Frequently Asked Questions About High Point Restaurant
What is the dining style and specialty of High Point Restaurant?
High Point Restaurant specializes in fine dining, offering gourmet dishes including steaks, seafood, pasta, salads, soups, and wine.
Where is High Point Restaurant located?
The restaurant is located at 224 E Main St, Monteagle, TN 37356, USA.
What are the opening hours of High Point Restaurant?
High Point Restaurant is open Monday to Thursday and Sunday from 5:00 PM to 9:00 PM, on Friday until 10:00 PM, and on Saturday from 4:00 PM to 10:00 PM.
Are reservations required to dine at High Point Restaurant?
Yes, reservations are required to dine at High Point Restaurant.
What is special about the building where High Point Restaurant is located?
The restaurant is housed in a 1929 mansion, once presumably financed by Al Capone, featuring original escape hatches and underground tunnels used during the Prohibition Era. It is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
How can I contact High Point Restaurant for reservations or inquiries?
You can contact them by phone at +1 931-924-4600 or email at highpointrestaurant@yahoo.com.
What payment methods does High Point Restaurant accept?
They accept American Express, Cash, Discover, Mastercard, and Visa.
Which nearby attractions can I visit before or after dining at High Point Restaurant?
Nearby attractions include the Monteagle Mountain Market for Arts & Crafts, Hannah Pickett Adventure Playground, and May Justus Memorial Library, perfect for exploring local culture and outdoor activities.
Are there any notable local dining options near High Point Restaurant?
Yes, Paco’s Tacos Of Monteagle TN offers tacos and smoothies, and Shan Chinese Buffet provides Chinese cuisine nearby.
What nearby facilities might be useful for visitors to High Point Restaurant?
Nearby facilities include Mountain Valley Bank and Citizens Tri-County Bank for financial services, and the Post Office-Monteagle for postal needs.