Long John Silver's

3.9
806 reviews
Seacret Society

About

Fast Food RestaurantSeafood RestaurantTake Out RestaurantChicken Restaurant
Real seafood should be sourced from real sea-places, like, you know, oceans. So that's exactly where we source our wild-caught Alaska pollock, wild-caught Alaska salmon, and wild-caught north Pacific cod. We’re no one trick sea pony.

Details

  • Dine-inAvailable
  • DeliveryAvailable
  • TakeoutAvailable
  • Credit cardAvailable

Location

Long John Silver's
1739 E. 3rd St., Williamsport, PA
17701, United States

Hours

Reviews

3.9
806 reviews
5 stars
361
4 stars
200
3 stars
113
2 stars
47
1 star
85

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Food Quality

Many customers reported that the food was overcooked, greasy, and overly salted, leading to dissatisfaction with the taste.

Service Issues

Several reviews mentioned slow service, forgotten items in orders, and a lack of staff, contributing to a negative dining experience.

Cleanliness

The restaurant was frequently described as dirty, with unclean seating areas and poorly maintained facilities.

Pricing Concerns

Customers expressed frustration over high prices for small portions, feeling that the value for money had declined.

Staff Friendliness

Despite the issues, some customers praised the staff for being friendly and accommodating, highlighting positive interactions.
  • NT
    Nancy Toles
    Nov 9, 2025
    4.0
    I love your food. I really like your salmon platter with shrimp.Can I have it without hot spicy spices on top the salmon and Shrimp .other than that the platter was great.Tge spices upset my stomach. I love Salmon for a change .Also can I get the sauses ,and catsup,the sides A lot of times when we get home something is missing. Other than that I love long John's. Thank you so much . NANCY .
  • KM
    kevin morrison
    Oct 24, 2025
    3.0
    Ordered three piece fish meal, asked for extra tarter sauce, on three different occasions, was assured that I got it, only to receive three sauces. This is my third visit since they reopened. Never received it. It's almost like they want to fight you just for wanting extra sauce
  • BN
    Bonnie Nozisko
    Oct 18, 2025
    3.0
    The fish, chicken, fries and hush puppies were all over cooked and also tasted like it was cooked in used oil. All was way over salted but the fries you couldn’t even taste salt on the fries. But I guess they think cause everything else is so heavily salted they didn’t need to do the fries and the fries were the only thing I ordered for myself. You couldn’t taste the food it just tasted like grease. This is sad because it used to be one of my favorite places to eat. But will try again in maybe a few months after you keep getting reviews on how salty and greasy the food taste.
  • SC
    Sean Carlson
    Oct 15, 2025
    4.0
    The new building is very different from what it used to be. The staff was great and accommodating. The food was what I remembered, but they were very skimpy on the crispies .. Members of my generation will know what I'm talking about. 😃
  • WE
    Wendy Eigenbrod
    Oct 15, 2025
    4.0
    So this place recently reopened, I honestly haven't eaten here in years. I was pleasantly surprised that the food was hot and good. We ordered online and picked it up. I would go back again

Frequently Asked Questions About Long John Silver's

Can I order online and pickup in store?

Yes! Order online and pickup in store at participating Long John Silver's restaurants. Find your local LJS here: https://www.ljsilvers.com/locations

Can I see a menu?

You can see a menu here: https://www.ljsilvers.com/menu/