Mixed reviews on food quality; some customers enjoyed the pizza and subs, while others found items bland or poorly prepared.
Service Issues
Customers reported inconsistent service, including long wait times and unprofessional behavior from staff.
Pricing Concerns
Many customers felt the prices were too high for the quality of food received.
Customer Experience
Positive feedback on friendly staff and helpful service, but also complaints about rude interactions and lack of attention to customers.
BW
Becky Watson
5 days ago
5.0
I always enjoy doing takeout at Brothers. It’s always read, hot and the people are so friendly and nice.
CO
Carrie O'Brien
6 days ago
5.0
Food is amazing! Best Stromboli’s around !!
BC
Blaine C.
Dec 10, 2025
5.0
Ordered two large pizzas for pickup. Both were ready at my scheduled time, service was friendly, and pizza was excellent.
DS
Damian Simmons
Nov 14, 2025
2.0
Ordered at around 8 for about $26 you can get bland tasteless French fries, a bland cheesesteak, and a cannoli that has to be store bought given the contrast in quality from the other food items (though I cannot confirm). Mind you this is my first impression of this place. I would advise going somewhere else with better quality food items.
SD
Sue Dickman
Oct 27, 2025
2.0
I go to this Brother's pizza about once a week. I always tip even though it is over the counter service. I ordered a meatball parm sandwich. The bun was so well done that it was black across whole top and sides of one end. Can't believe that they brought it out like that! The bun was so over baked, tried to eat the bun but ended up eating just the meatballs and cheese. I was so disappointed Don't know if I will be back.