Customers frequently praised the friendly and attentive service, although some noted inconsistencies and slow response times.
Food Quality
While many enjoyed the food, there were several complaints about undercooked or poorly prepared dishes, with some customers expressing disappointment in the overall quality.
Pricing
Several reviews mentioned that the prices felt high for the quality of food received, with some customers feeling that they could find better value elsewhere.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's cozy, down-home vibe was appreciated by many, contributing to a nostalgic dining experience.
Consistency
There were mixed reviews regarding the consistency of food quality and service, with some customers expressing a desire for improvement.
AA
Angela
1 day ago
5.0
The chicken is the best I ever had. The crust was crunchy and so flavorful. The meat was moist and tender.
DR
David Richwine
Dec 23, 2025
5.0
Nice sweet people they always have a beautiful smile
DD
Deb Digioia
Dec 6, 2025
4.0
Ordered breakfast for two. Portions were generous. The bacon and toast were overcooked but the eggs and pancakes were quite good. We had some difficulty getting service and coffee refills although there were several servers and few customers late morning. We will try them again- perhaps it was just an off day.
JD
John Duff
Dec 2, 2025
4.0
Applesauce was not included
Meatloaf was good side order of fries was fries other side Applesauce was missing
MR
Mr. Review
Oct 13, 2025
3.0
First time visiting so here is my take! Was it good? Yes. Was it affordable? Definitely on the higher side. Was it worth it? While the food was good I've had better at a lower price point from other local hometown places.
First time being here. We walked in and immediately you had that flash back of simpler times or in some aspects it felt like the dinner scene in every movie I've ever seen. Not that was a bad thing. The staff was friendly and welcoming no problems there.
The food was good. Nothing stood out and made me want to buy dessert but then again we were never asked if we wanted any anyway. Shelled out about $105 for lunch for a family of 4 with the tip.
Everywhere I go I have to try the Chile. It was okay but more of a tomato taste than anything. A cup ran just under $7. I tried the grilled bacon chicken wrap. I don't believe it came with sauce on it? I think that was $11 or $12 by itself. No fries or anything included. I really miss the days when fries were included but slap on another $4.29 for fries? So you near almost $20 with fries and a drink per person with whatever main item you want.
While the staff was good, the food was decent, the prices were higher. Next time I'd do take out to save some money for sure!
Frequently Asked Questions About Studebaker's Country Restaurant
What are the regular operating hours of Studebaker's Country Restaurant?
Studebaker's Country Restaurant is open Monday through Saturday from 6:00 AM to 8:00 PM, and Sunday from 7:00 AM to 3:00 PM.
Does Studebaker's Country Restaurant offer delivery and pickup options?
Yes, Studebaker's Country Restaurant offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.
Are there any holiday closures for Studebaker's Country Restaurant?
Yes, the restaurant is closed on July 4th each year, including upcoming years from 2026 to 2034.
Where is Studebaker's Country Restaurant located?
It is located at 416 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344, United States.
How can I view the menu or place an order online for Studebaker's Country Restaurant?
You can view the menu and place an order online at https://studebakerscountryrestaurants.com/menu.
What type of cuisine and dining experience does Studebaker's Country Restaurant offer?
Studebaker's offers American and Southern cuisine including breakfast, brunch, sandwiches, fried chicken, and hamburgers in a family-friendly diner setting.
Which nearby places can I visit after dining at Studebaker's Country Restaurant?
After dining, you might visit nearby spots like Gyro House for Mediterranean cuisine, or stop by Marathon gas station for convenience items or coffee.
Are there any nearby financial services close to Studebaker's Country Restaurant?
Yes, nearby financial services include CoinFlip Bitcoin ATM, Western Union money transfer services, and NCF Savings Bank.
What nearby health and medical services are close to Studebaker's Country Restaurant?
Nearby health services include Honeycreek Urgent Care, New Carlisle Family Practice, and New Carlisle Animal Hospital.
Can customers combine a visit to Studebaker's Country Restaurant with other shopping or service needs nearby?
Yes, customers can visit nearby businesses such as Dollar General for discount shopping, Bello Hair Salon or Shear Madness for hair care, and Mr. Mac's Discount Grocery Outlet for groceries and bakery items.