Business Details
About
American RestaurantRestaurantBar & GrillTavernBarSports BarPub
Rusty Bucket, located in New Albany, OH, is a casual neighborhood tavern serving high quality food and beverage in a "come as you are" setting. Scratch kitchens, fresh cocktails, and the perfect pour are our craft. Our associates are welcoming, and our hospitality naturally makes us the local hub where friends and family frequently gather to share in a good time. Join us for lunch, grab a drink during Happy Hour, bring the kids for dinner - there's a spot for everyone at Rusty Bucket!
Details
- Dine-inAvailable
- DeliveryAvailable
- TakeoutNot available
- Accepts reservationsAvailable
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.4
1,420 reviews
5 stars
885
4 stars
369
3 stars
104
2 stars
34
1 star
28
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
While many customers praised the food as delicious and consistent, some reported issues with specific dishes being overcooked or poorly prepared.
Service
Service quality varied; several reviews highlighted excellent and attentive staff, while others noted slow service or unacknowledged wait times.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's atmosphere received positive feedback for being cozy and welcoming, though some customers expressed disappointment with seating arrangements during busy times.
Value
Some customers felt the prices were high for the quality of food received, particularly with takeout orders.
- BZBarb Zimmerman3 days ago5.0Great food, staff and atmosphere.
- BCBrendan CJan 5, 20265.0Wonderful experience at Rusty Bucket in New Albany! The chicken tenders were cooked to perfection, and the staff was so welcoming. I was seated right away, which was a huge plus. Will definitely be back!
- MLMichael LaceyDec 14, 20253.0The food was fine but the bartender can jam enough ice in a drink so you can get about an ounce of a drink. Bush league.
- CRCallum RennerDec 12, 20251.0Did a takeout order, and they left plastic on the cheese for my cheeseburger 😐. I don’t think I need to explain why I left a 1 star.
- PMPayton MacallDec 10, 20255.0I loved the atmosphere. The food was 10/10 cannot believe being a Louisiana boy I’ve had this much luck with finding great food. Will be back for my annual work trip.
Frequently Asked Questions About Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern
Does the Rusty Bucket have a Happy Hour?
Yes! Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern offers special pricing on select items Monday through Friday from 3:00 – 6:00 pm. Happy Hour offerings are not limited to the bar area, so guests can enjoy these specials anywhere in the restaurant or on the patio. The Rusty Bucket’s Happy Hour menu includes 1/2 off Apps, $12 Pizzas, $7 Juicy Lucy Burgers, and $1 off Beer, Wine & Cocktails.
Does the Rusty Bucket offer specialty cocktails?
Yes! The Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern offers the perfect cocktail for everyone. The cocktail menu consists of the Cold Brew Martini, Rusty Bucket’s own version of an espresso martini, the Pine Fin, served on the rocks, as a martini, or as a cosmo, two cocktails on draft, the Draft Bucket Punch and the Draft Margarita, and many more delicious drinks. Features may change – to see the full, most current cocktail list.
Can the Rusty Bucket accommodate large parties?
The Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern offers various private dining options across many of their locations. Seating ranges from 10 to 55 guests, dependent upon location, which includes the option of their 4-season, private dining patios. It’s best to call your local Rusty Bucket to discuss your plans and complete your reservation.
What kind of restaurant is the Rusty Bucket?
The Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern is a casual American restaurant and tavern serving the highest quality of food and beverage in a “come as you are” setting. Whether you are celebrating a birthday or anniversary, or having a business dinner, the Rusty Bucket believes that every neighborhood deserves that go-to gathering place where craveable favorites, good conversations, and camaraderie are shared amongst friends and family. Everybody’s welcome, and some even say the Rusty Bucket is a grown-up place to bring the kids.
Does the Rusty Bucket offer Brunch?
No, the Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern does not offer a Brunch menu. Each location offers a lunch menu every day of the week. We recommend calling your local Rusty Bucket for hours of operation.
What’s the Rusty Bucket famous for?
The Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern is famous for their great Happy Hour specials, offered Monday through Friday from 3:00 – 6:00 pm, where you can receive special pricing on select menu items, including 1/2 off Apps, $12 Pizzas, and more.Some of Rusty Bucket’s menu items that stand out include their Fish & Chips, Bucket Burger, and variety of Artisan Pizzas, which are handmade with dough that is made fresh daily. They also offer a range of handcrafted cocktails, as well as a robust beer list with a few local brewery collaborations from time to time.Rusty Bucket’s atmosphere is known to most as a go-to gathering place for any occasion. Whether you are celebrating a birthday, having a business dinner, or watching sports or indulging before or after a big game, it is the perfect place for everyone.
Is there patio seating?
Yes! Most Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern locations offer patio seating, dependent upon location, and some even offer four-season availability. We recommend calling your local Rusty Bucket for more details about these options.
Where’s the best place to park?
The Rusty Bucket Restaurant & Tavern offers free parking with a designated parking lot.
Are Reservations required?
Reservations are not required but they are recommended. The dining room can be particularly busy in the later part of the week. If OpenTable is showing no availability for your preferred day and time, we recommend calling your local Rusty Bucket.
Does the Rusty Bucket offer any fundraising options?
Yes! The Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern has a program called Dine ‘n Donate. Any guests who are a part of an organization looking to raise funds can participate in the Dine ‘n Donate program. Guests can choose a date, Monday-Thursday, the Rusty Bucket will create a flyer, and supporters of the organization can dine in or order carryout any time during business hours on that chosen day. On that chosen date, anyone who presents the flyer will have 15% of net sales (food and soft beverages) donated to the organization. For more information or to fill out the Dine ‘n Donate request form.
Does the Rusty Bucket have any specials throughout the week?
Yes! The Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern offers Daily Drink Features for every day of the week. These features include Monday Motivation- $5 Wheatley vodka all day long, Poppin’ Bottles Tuesday- 1/2 priced bottles of wine, Whiskey Wednesday- specially priced whiskeys, Punch Perfect Thursday- Bucket’s House Bucket Punch on draft by the glass or pitcher, Shaken Not Stirred Friday- specially priced Belvedere martinis, Pine Fin Cosmos & Pine Fin Martinis, Gary’s Famous Margarita Saturday- share a pitcher (or drink a glass yourself), and Bloody Sunday- specially priced Bloody Marys; choose from Not Spicy, Spicy or Stupid Spicy.
Does the Rusty Bucket have a loyalty program?
The Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern offers the Bucket List, an exclusive subscriber list. When you join the Bucket List, you receive a Bucket full of benefits including being the first to know about happenings and new features at the Rusty Bucket, exclusive deals sent straight to your inbox, and a complimentary dessert during your birthday month! Join the Bucket List!
Does the Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern offer Happy Hour specials?
Yes, Rusty Bucket offers Happy Hour specials Monday through Friday from 3:00 – 6:00 pm with discounts on select appetizers, pizzas, burgers, and drinks available anywhere in the restaurant or patio.
Are specialty cocktails available at Rusty Bucket?
Yes, Rusty Bucket offers a variety of specialty cocktails including the Cold Brew Martini, Pine Fin, Draft Bucket Punch, Draft Margarita, and other rotating drink options.
Can Rusty Bucket accommodate large parties or private events?
Yes, Rusty Bucket offers private dining options seating from 10 to 55 guests, including some locations with four-season private patios. It is recommended to call the location for reservations and details.
What type of cuisine and atmosphere does Rusty Bucket provide?
Rusty Bucket is a casual American restaurant and tavern serving high-quality food in a welcoming “come as you are” setting, ideal for celebrations, business dinners, or casual gatherings with family and friends.
Is there patio seating available at Rusty Bucket?
Most Rusty Bucket locations offer patio seating, some with four-season availability. It's best to contact your local Rusty Bucket for specific details.
What are Rusty Bucket’s hours of operation?
Rusty Bucket is open Monday through Thursday from 11:00 am to 10:00 pm, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 am to 11:00 pm, and Sunday from 11:00 am to 9:00 pm.
How can I make a reservation at Rusty Bucket?
Reservations are recommended, especially on busy days. You can reserve a table online via Rusty Bucket’s website or call the location directly if online availability is limited.
What nearby places can I visit before or after dining at Rusty Bucket?
Near Rusty Bucket, you can visit New Albany Market Square for shopping and events, Whit’s Frozen Custard for dessert, or enjoy a coffee at the nearby Starbucks, all within easy walking distance.
Are there transportation or parking options near Rusty Bucket to help customers find the location?
Rusty Bucket offers free designated parking at their location. Nearby points of interest such as New Albany Market Square and local financial services can help orient visitors in the area.
What family-friendly services are available near Rusty Bucket?
Families can find child care services at Jovie of New Albany and educational support at College Nannies, Sitters + Tutors nearby, making it convenient to combine dining at Rusty Bucket with family needs.