Business Details
About
Mexican Restaurant
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.3
1,519 reviews
5 stars
871
4 stars
375
3 stars
133
2 stars
71
1 star
69
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Many customers found the food bland and lacking seasoning, with several specific complaints about portion sizes and flavor.
Service Experience
Service quality varied significantly; while some reviews praised friendly and attentive staff, others reported rude or inattentive service.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's atmosphere was generally well-received, with many noting a lively vibe, though some found the music too loud.
Value for Money
Several customers expressed dissatisfaction with the pricing relative to portion sizes and food quality, feeling it was overpriced.
Consistency
There were mixed reviews regarding consistency in food quality and service, with some customers experiencing great meals while others were disappointed.
- GIGian Inder4 days ago5.0Stopped while traveling through the area. Food was delicious! Service was amazing!!! (Thank you Lili!) Bathrooms clean and nice! Would come back here again and again!
- CMCarol MartyNov 6, 20252.0Have gone there for years, but recently it has really gone downhill! Was there a couple of nights ago. The music was way too loud. Couldn’t even hear your table mate. There were several waiters and only 3 tables of guests, but it took them 30 minutes to take our order. The prices have gone up but the food portions have gone down and it seems so has the quality of the food. I got a taco salad. There was Very Little meat in the bottom. Just about all shredded lettuce, 1 tomato slice and a dollop of sour cream. During the night I became ill with stomach cramps, headache and chills, all symptoms of e-coli. So I’s wondering how diligent these new waiters are about personal hygiene. All in all, I won’t be going back there again!
- JBJames BerkleyNov 5, 20252.0They used to have the best homemade guacamole and now it's gone downhill a lot. The staff very helpful very nice people. The kids meals are reasonably priced but just reheated frozen food. Which isn't really a bad thing for my family because my kids really don't like spices. They do have some really good steak tacos. I get them American style with a flower tortilla. In my mind is the best thing on the menu now that the guacamole is not as good as it used to be. It's not bad just not as good as it used to be.
- DLDonnie LeblancOct 31, 20252.0Food was bland, service was so so,buddy ordered Beef nachos with the fixings they had mushrooms and carrots mixed in never have I ever seen mushrooms and carrots on nachos 😂
- CSCindy SOct 22, 20255.0This place is next to my gym so I had to try it! We had a good dinner, restaurant had a nice Fl vibe, clean, employees were friendly and polite. Ordered Chicken sriracha, it may not be the most Mexican but it had good flavors, chicken was grilled and tender. Also ordered the Queso fundido with shrimp, it came with freshly made flour tortillas 👍 Will go back next time to try different dishes
Frequently Asked Questions About Blue Agave
What are the regular business hours of Blue Agave?
Blue Agave is open daily from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, except on Sundays when it closes at 9:00 PM.
Does Blue Agave offer delivery and/or pickup services?
Blue Agave offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.
Where is Blue Agave located?
Blue Agave is located at 9745 Johnstown Rd, New Albany, OH 43054, USA.
Where can I view the menu and place an order for Blue Agave?
You can view the menu and place orders online at https://blueagaverestaurants.com/menu.
What types of cuisine does Blue Agave specialize in?
Blue Agave specializes in Mexican, Tex-Mex, burritos, tacos, seafood, and vegetarian dishes.
What price range can I expect at Blue Agave?
Blue Agave has a price range categorized as 'TWO', indicating moderate pricing.
What are the takeout hours for Blue Agave?
The takeout hours are from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM Monday through Saturday, and 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM on Sundays.
Are there any gyms near Blue Agave for a post-meal workout?
Yes, nearby gyms include F45 Training New Albany, Soma Lab Fitness, Snap Fitness, Cross Fit New Albany, and PRISM Performance.
What nearby coffee shops can I visit before or after dining at Blue Agave?
You can visit nearby coffee shops such as Tim Hortons and Dunkin' for a coffee break before or after your meal.
Are there any beauty salons near Blue Agave for grooming services?
Yes, nearby beauty salons include Saturday's hair salon, New Nails nail and beauty salon, and Knockouts Haircuts for Men barber and massage.