Pizza Cottage - Lancaster (Main St)
4.2192 reviews
Certified by Pizza Cottage - Lancaster (Main St) • Feb 08, 2026
Business Details
1961 E Main St, Lancaster, OH
43130, United States
Certified by Pizza Cottage - Lancaster (Main St) • Feb 08, 2026
(740) 277-6289
Certified by Pizza Cottage - Lancaster (Main St) • Feb 08, 2026
https://www.pizza-cottage.com/
Certified by Pizza Cottage - Lancaster (Main St) • Feb 08, 2026
About
Certified by Pizza Cottage - Lancaster (Main St) • Feb 08, 2026
Pizza RestaurantRestaurantChicken Wings RestaurantSports Bar
Craving authentic pizza in Lancaster, OH? Pizza Cottage has you covered! Our pizzeria makes each pizza with the freshest ingredients, guaranteeing a burst of flavor in every bite. Proudly serving the community, we’re not just about pizza; our menu also features an array of mouthwatering options, including hot subs, calzones, wings, and much more, perfect for any appetite. At our local pizzeria, every slice tells a story of tradition, quality, and the freshest, locally-sourced ingredients. At the heart of Pizza Cottage is our exceptional team. More than just staff, they are the essence of our establishment – friendly, passionate about food, and always eager to make your dining experience extraordinary. Call our local pizzeria today!
Location
Certified by Pizza Cottage - Lancaster (Main St) • Feb 08, 2026
Pizza Cottage - Lancaster (Main St)
1961 E Main St, Lancaster, OH
43130, United States
Hours
Certified by Pizza Cottage - Lancaster (Main St) • Feb 08, 2026
Reviews
4.2
192 reviews
5 stars
116
4 stars
38
3 stars
11
2 stars
5
1 star
22
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Mixed reviews on food quality, with some praising specific pizzas like the BLT and Thai chili chicken, while others reported issues with burnt or soggy pizzas.
Service Issues
Numerous complaints about slow service, rude staff, and poor customer service experiences, particularly with order mistakes and management responses.
Atmosphere
Generally positive feedback on the restaurant's atmosphere, with some noting it as a nice place to eat, though there were mentions of cleanliness issues.
Customer Loyalty
Despite some negative experiences, many customers expressed loyalty to the brand, citing it as their go-to pizza place.
- TSTed SmithJan 14, 20261.0Called and placed an order. Pizza was ready when I got there. The service was pretty good. The down fall,, probably the worst pizza ive ever had. Speedway pizza is better and thats really saying something.
- AMAlexes MaxeyJan 2, 20263.0Pizza was ok, server was nice, but service was very slow
- JWJohn WoganDec 22, 20255.0Great food
- KCKimberly J ConradDec 11, 20255.0Stopped in to do a future order...
- MLMichelle LoraNov 17, 20251.0I came into Town visiting from Georgia my family raved about how good this pizza was. I made my order online and this is how my pizza look with no cheese. I called to let them know. My pizza had no cheese or hardly any cheese and they transferred me to who was supposed to be the manager and she told me she made it herself and that I asked for a pizza with half cheese the other half no cheese as you can see I guess this was the half that was supposed to have cheese on it. The online ordering confused me and I guess I ordered a pizza with only half of it with cheese. I tried to explain to her, not even half the pizza had cheese on it, and she hung up on me mid conversation. I called back and she told me to stop calling this is what I ordered and she’s not gonna fix it for me and hung up on me again. I was not being rude. I was not cussing. I was just trying to get this situation fixed. I wouldn’t recommend this location on Main Street to anyone. And if this is How the management treats customers you should get new management.
Frequently Asked Questions About Pizza Cottage - Lancaster (Main St)
Does Pizza Cottage offer catering or party rooms?
Yes, we offer party rooms at some locations, and we provide food truck services for events as well!
Does Pizza Cottage participate in fundraising or community events?
Yes, we are committed to giving back to the community through our "Eat Pizza. Raise Dough." program, which helps organizations raise money, and sponsor various charitable and business events.
Is there a surcharge on Pizza Cottage orders?
Due to rising costs, Pizza Cottage has implemented a 3% surcharge on orders to help manage increased labor and operational expenses. This surcharge is not a sales tax.
Does Pizza Cottage have a food truck?
Yes, we have a food truck that is available for private events, corporate lunches, or fairs & festivals. Contact us or visit our website for availability and booking!
What are the operating hours of Pizza Cottage - Lancaster (Main St)?
Pizza Cottage is open Monday to Thursday and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, and on Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM.
Does Pizza Cottage offer catering services or party rooms for events?
Yes, Pizza Cottage offers party rooms at some locations and provides food truck services for events.
Is there an extra surcharge applied to orders at Pizza Cottage?
Due to rising costs, Pizza Cottage has implemented a 3% surcharge on orders to help manage increased labor and operational expenses; this is not a sales tax.
Does Pizza Cottage participate in community events or fundraising?
Yes, Pizza Cottage supports the community through their 'Eat Pizza. Raise Dough.' program and sponsors various charitable and business events.
Is there a Pizza Cottage food truck available?
Yes, Pizza Cottage has a food truck available for private events, corporate lunches, and festivals. Contact them or visit their website for booking information.
What types of food can I expect at Pizza Cottage - Lancaster (Main St)?
Pizza Cottage offers authentic pizza made with fresh ingredients, as well as hot subs, calzones, wings, and more to satisfy various appetites.
How can the nearby Lancaster Eagles Aerie 2120 benefit visitors to Pizza Cottage?
Visitors to Pizza Cottage can enjoy social and community events at Lancaster Eagles Aerie 2120, located nearby, making it convenient to combine dining with community gatherings.
Are there nearby services for pet care around Pizza Cottage?
Yes, Fairfield Pet Hospital and VCA Fairfield Animal Hospital are nearby, providing pet grooming, veterinary services, and other pet care options for customers visiting Pizza Cottage.
Where can I find automotive services near Pizza Cottage?
Nearby automotive services include Steve's Used Autos (used car dealer), Lancaster Main Car Wash, Precise Auto and Motorcycle Detailing, and R & S Automotive for repair and detailing needs.
How can nearby gas stations assist customers visiting Pizza Cottage?
Customers driving to Pizza Cottage can conveniently refuel at nearby gas stations such as Marathon Gas, Certified Oil, and Cumberland Farms before or after their meal.
Brand Certified Facts from Pizza Cottage - Lancaster (Main St)
Pizza Cottage - Lancaster (Main St) partners directly with Yext to publish this data from the brand's official system of record. Learn more about our data sources
Certified February 08, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
- Address
- Categories
- Geo coordinates
- Legal business name
- Hours of operation
- Phone number
- Official website