only come to the Melt Shop at the Staten Island Mall because of the employees they are always so friendly, welcoming, and helpful. The staff really goes above and beyond to make you feel like a valued customer, and that’s the main reason I stop by.
As for the food, it’s honestly pretty average and overpriced for what you get. The flavors and portions don’t quite live up to the cost, so it’s not somewhere I’d recommend if you’re going purely for the food. But the team behind the counter makes the experience much better than it would be otherwise.
If Melt Shop ever matched the quality of the food with the quality of the staff,
LS
Lamar Sanders
May 3, 2025
5.0
Food was really good. The manager Jada, was really sweet and gave excellent customer service. She looked really busy but she stopped what she was doing and offered to help me with no problem. Give her a raise! She alone deserves 5 stars but I’ll give it to the whole store instead!
LA
Leana Atieh
Aug 25, 2024
1.0
If I could give zero stars, I would. Absolutely horrible customer service. No accountability whatsoever. The first time my son placed an order with them for delivery, they forgot to include the burger- this was 1/3 of the meal. Also the first item in the order but somehow it was missed and somehow it was Uber eats fault. Then when we called to get a refund, they said they would issue it and never did. Now I have to go out of my way to go to the restaurant to get my money for food I never received because the staff is incompetent and doesn’t know how to issue a refund to a credit card. Definitely would never recommend. You will waste your money and time.
JC
James C
Feb 10, 2019
5.0
The food was delicious and served hot. The order was correct and the workers were nice and courteous. The prices were within range. I had the vegan melt and my wife had a bacon cheese melt.
What payment methods are accepted at Melt Shop Staten Island Mall?
Melt Shop accepts American Express, Android Pay, Apple Pay, Cash, MasterCard, Samsung Pay, and Visa.
Is Melt Shop accessible for customers with disabilities?
Yes, Melt Shop has a wheelchair accessible entrance to accommodate customers with disabilities.
Can I order food online from Melt Shop at Staten Island Mall?
Yes, you can place orders online via their website at http://order.meltshop.com/menu/1015-staten-island-ny.
Does Melt Shop serve vegetarian or children's menu options?
Yes, Melt Shop serves vegetarian options and has a children's menu available.
What nearby stores can I visit at Staten Island Mall when dining at Melt Shop?
Nearby stores include babyGap, GUESS, Clarks, Cotton On, Charlotte Russe, Ardene, and adidas Store Staten Island for clothing, shoes, and accessories.
Are there other dining options near Melt Shop in Staten Island Mall?
Yes, nearby dining options include Taco Bell, Auntie Anne's, Poke Island & Grill, Applebee's Grill + Bar, The Mighty Crab, and Red Robin Gourmet Burgers and Brews.
What nearby amenities are available for health and wellness near Melt Shop?
Close to Melt Shop, you can find Sterling Optical, Visionworks, Davis Visionworks for eye care, and Threading Station for beauty and hair salon services.