Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

3.5
271 reviews
Get DirectionsCallWebsite

Business Details

4000 Lake Avenue, Rochester, NY
14612, United States
(585) 663-4000
https://salvatores.com/locations/lake
GoogleFacebookInstagramTwitter

About

Pizza RestaurantTake Out RestaurantRestaurant Delivery ServiceChicken Wings Restaurant
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria is a beloved multi-location pizzeria headquartered in Rochester, NY since 1978! We serve up delicious pizzas that are crafted with the finest ingredients. Our diverse menu includes classic and gourmet pizzas, mouth-watering wings, subs, salads, pasta dishes, and more. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or enjoying our efficient delivery service, you'll experience the same high quality and exceptional taste that has made us a local favorite. Catering services are also available for events of any size. Visit one of our convenient locations to taste Rochester's Favorite Pizza!

Details

  • Dine-inAvailable
  • DeliveryAvailable
  • TakeoutAvailable
  • Accepts reservationsNot available

Location

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria
4000 Lake Avenue, Rochester, NY
14612, United States

Hours

Reviews

3.5
268 reviews
5 stars
114
4 stars
46
3 stars
28
2 stars
17
1 star
63

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Customer Service

Many customers reported rude and unhelpful staff, particularly when addressing order issues or complaints.

Order Accuracy

Numerous reviews highlighted issues with incorrect orders, missing items, and poor attention to special requests.

Food Quality

While some customers praised the pizza, many others complained about cold, overcooked, or poorly prepared food.

Pricing Concerns

Several customers felt that the prices were too high for the quality and portion sizes received.

Delivery Issues

Customers frequently mentioned long wait times for delivery and orders arriving cold or incorrect.
  • KC
    Katelynn Crouse
    Nov 15, 2025
    1.0
    I usually order here a lot but last night the sub tasted moldy and I inspected the bread assuming it was the bread that was moldy and no mold..I saved half my sub for lunch next day and took a bite and noticed it still tasted like mold so I spit it out and opened the sub and seen there was mold on the cheddar cheese they served me and obviously they don't inspect there food closely or following the fifo method and discarding old cheese when it's suppose too. Check you food if you order here but they will no longer get my service..this was there first mess up and now I'm not sure I can trust to eat there... The manager begged me not to post this and offered me free food but I don't want other to consume this mold like I did and hopefully I don't get sick and I have photo evidence. Sad I have to depart from this restaurant and they have served us well and made good food. Sorry I gave to do this and post anyways so others don't get this .
  • RM
    Roger May
    Nov 15, 2025
    1.0
    I ordered 2 subs last night and they both were late and the hot sun was cold and the cold sub for my wife the cheese had mold in its absolutely disgusting and unsafe to prepare food with such carelessness
  • LB
    Legg Bench
    Sep 3, 2025
    3.0
    Was ok.
  • SH
    Sour Hour
    Aug 10, 2025
    1.0
    They are very rude on the phone
  • LC
    Linda Carr
    Jul 31, 2025
    5.0
    Had an awesome pizza from there this evening. Crust was delicately crisp, soft and chewy inside, generous toppings and the best sauce.
Read more reviews on Google

Frequently Asked Questions About Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

What types of pickup and delivery services does Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria offer?

Salvatore's offers in-store pickup, curbside pickup, delivery, same day delivery, and no-contact delivery services.

What meals are served at Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria?

They serve breakfast, lunch, brunch, dinner, happy hour, and late night meals.