Business Details
About
Irish RestaurantAmerican RestaurantBrunch RestaurantBar & Grill
Located near the High Line Trail and Hudson Yards, O'Toole's Way offers a dynamic dining experience that blends traditional Irish cuisine with modern culinary creativity. Our menu features inventive and flavorful dishes, rooted in classic techniques and inspired by Ireland’s rich culinary heritage. Whether you're savoring hearty, comforting favorites or exploring fresh, seasonal creations, every bite is crafted with care. Complement your meal with our thoughtfully curated cocktail menu, highlighting seasonal ingredients, or choose from our extensive selection of beer and wine, perfect for any occasion. Whether you're planning a corporate outing, a lively gathering with friends, or a cozy dinner, our warm and inviting space provides the ideal setting for an unforgettable dining experience.
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.7
479 reviews
5 stars
413
4 stars
31
3 stars
14
2 stars6
1 star
15
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Service Quality
Many customers praised the attentive and friendly service, particularly highlighting servers like Gabriella and Camila.
Food Quality
Overall, the food received positive feedback, with specific mentions of delicious dishes like the Irish Breakfast and burgers, though some customers noted inconsistencies.
Atmosphere
The atmosphere was generally described as welcoming and enjoyable, making it a good spot for casual dining and drinks.
Management Issues
A few reviews pointed out negative experiences with management, particularly regarding customer service and handling complaints.
Pricing Concerns
Some customers felt that prices were high, especially for certain menu items, which affected their overall satisfaction.
- MMMimiNov 17, 20255.0What a fantastic spot! We met up with family and friends and spent a wonderful Saturday afternoon enjoying a pint (or two) of Guinness, refreshing cocktails, and some delicious small bites. The atmosphere is lively and inviting, with plenty of space at the bar. Paula is an incredible bartender, fun, engaging, and a joy to chat with. If you are in the Hudson Yards neighborhood, definitely stop by for a drink or two!
- DLDonna LauserNov 16, 20255.0We loved every minute we spent at O’tooles Way. We unexpectedly arrived an hour before our reservation time but enjoyed spending that extra time we had at the bar. Bartender was amazing and attentive. We had the delicious chips with onion dip at the bar with our drinks. Once we were seated we were very pleased with our waitress Gabriella. She was helpful with our questions about the menu and very attentive the whole time. For appetizers we had the Guinness bbq wings and the leek and potato soup. Both delicious!! For dinner we chose the short rib cottage pie and the “DANGEROUS DAVE’S” Dublin Dip. Both were absolutely amazing. We were too stuffed to order dessert but hoping to do so next time!
- ACAshley CheretesNov 15, 20255.0Come see Camila at this wonderful restaurant. The food was great - the espresso rub ribs, the Irish spice bag, and my kids loved their meals as well (margherita pizza and cheese burger). Highly recommend for the family.
- DWDeborah WallaceNov 9, 20255.0My husband and I had a wonderful dining experience at O’Toole’s Way!! Our bartender Lavaniya was extremely friendly and professional. The manager Kelly was very welcoming and checked on us after our food arrived. The setting in Hudson Yards is beautiful. I highly recommend the restaurant and staff! Excellent service!
- WTWalter TonksNov 8, 20255.0When I was last in NYC, I stopped by O’Toole’s Way and it was incredible. Massive compliments to Culinary Director Barry Tonks and his team of chefs , I have eaten at a lot of restaurants in this company his menu and food choices are amazing . I had the Dangerous Dave’s Dublin Dip with fries tossed in parmesan and truffle oil, and it was easily one of the best meals I’ve had in the city. Everything was packed with flavor and perfectly cooked. The atmosphere was lively but comfortable, and the service was spot on. This place is a must-try for anyone visiting NYC you won’t regret it.
Frequently Asked Questions About O'Toole's Way
Does O'Toole's Way accept reservations?
Yes, O'Toole's Way accepts reservations and you can book through their reservation page.
What are the kitchen hours at O'Toole's Way?
The kitchen is open daily from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM.
When is brunch served at O'Toole's Way?
Brunch is served on Saturdays and Sundays from 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM.
Does O'Toole's Way offer delivery service?
Yes, delivery is available and can be ordered online through their delivery URL.
What type of cuisine does O'Toole's Way specialize in?
O'Toole's Way offers a dynamic dining experience with traditional Irish cuisine blended with modern culinary creativity.
What is the dress code at O'Toole's Way?
The dress code is casual, making it a comfortable spot for any occasion.
What payment methods are accepted at O'Toole's Way?
They accept American Express, Apple Pay, MasterCard, and Visa.
Can you recommend nearby places to visit before or after dining at O'Toole's Way?
Guests can enjoy nearby attractions such as The High Line Trail and Hudson Yards, which are excellent for scenic walks and shopping experiences before or after your meal.
Are there convenient transit or ATM options near O'Toole's Way?
Yes, LibertyX Bitcoin ATM is nearby for quick currency exchange, and several convenience stores like Walgreens and Duane Reade are close for other essentials.
What nearby dining options are available around O'Toole's Way?
Nearby restaurants include Oyamel for Mexican cuisine, Leña for Spanish dishes, and Bar Celona, a tapas bar and restaurant, providing diverse dining alternatives.