Business Details
About
Irish RestaurantAmerican RestaurantBrunch RestaurantBar & Grill
Located near the High Line Trail and Hudson Yards, O'Toole's Way offers a dynamic dining experience that blends traditional Irish cuisine with modern culinary creativity. Our menu features inventive and flavorful dishes, rooted in classic techniques and inspired by Ireland’s rich culinary heritage. Whether you're savoring hearty, comforting favorites or exploring fresh, seasonal creations, every bite is crafted with care. Complement your meal with our thoughtfully curated cocktail menu, highlighting seasonal ingredients, or choose from our extensive selection of beer and wine, perfect for any occasion. Whether you're planning a corporate outing, a lively gathering with friends, or a cozy dinner, our warm and inviting space provides the ideal setting for an unforgettable dining experience.
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.7
577 reviews
5 stars
499
4 stars
40
3 stars
16
2 stars6
1 star
16
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Service Quality
Customers consistently praised the attentive and friendly service from various staff members, particularly highlighting servers like Camila, Gabriella, and Lavaniya.
Food Quality
The food received numerous compliments for its deliciousness, with specific dishes like the chicken sandwich, Dublin Dip, and sticky toffee pudding being frequently mentioned.
Atmosphere
The restaurant is noted for its lively and inviting atmosphere, making it a great spot for dining before events or for casual gatherings.
Customer Experience
Overall, many reviews reflected a positive dining experience, with several customers expressing their intention to return and recommend the restaurant to others.
- JDJean Doherty2 days ago5.0Camilla provided wonderful service and made our experience fabulous. Her recommendations were perfect and she was very attentive. Food was delicious. Highly recommend.
- AAAshley3 days ago5.0This place is so lovely! I would recommend to anyone visiting the high line! Geraldine was so friendly and attentive! Will definitely come back again soon!
- JMJeff MetzlerDec 31, 20254.0The place is clean, the staff is friendly and it served the purpose. It feels like a mall / corporate-made bar so if ur looking for an authentic local NYC bar, this isn’t really ur spot. It’s like a local Applebees/TGI Fridays (nicer tho).
- SRsharon russoDec 28, 20253.0The wait staff was friendly, attentive and professional. We ordered chips, burgers and chicken with waffles. The burgers tasted premade, not fresh meat and the buns were dry. The location is convenient but the food is average.
- MLMelanie LaFaveDec 21, 20255.0My friends and I day tripped to the city last Saturday. After looking around a bit for a place to eat we settled on O'Toole's Way and I'm so glad we did. They were very busy and had a short wait for a table so we asked if we could sit at the bar and they said we could. We ended up staying at the bar even after our table was ready. While waiting for the table we had ordered drinks and had decided to order some apps. I had an espresso martini made by the bartender, Lavaniya. It was amazing! We ordered the house chips and dip and the bar pie trio. The house chips and dip were out of this world..YUM. The bar pies were also fantastic, the toppings fresh and delicious. But the best part of the experience was hands down chatting with Lavaniya. She was so personable and attentive. We talked about our trip to the city and she gave us some tips on what to check out while we were there. We learned she had moved to the city 10 years ago and has become a permanent transplant. We are lucky to have you here, Lavaniya, thanks for the excellent service and friendly conversation. Until next time!
Frequently Asked Questions About O'Toole's Way
Does O'Toole's Way accept reservations?
Yes, O'Toole's Way accepts reservations and you can book through their reservation page.
What are the kitchen hours at O'Toole's Way?
The kitchen is open daily from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM.
When is brunch served at O'Toole's Way?
Brunch is served on Saturdays and Sundays from 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM.
Does O'Toole's Way offer delivery service?
Yes, delivery is available and can be ordered online through their delivery URL.
What type of cuisine does O'Toole's Way specialize in?
O'Toole's Way offers a dynamic dining experience with traditional Irish cuisine blended with modern culinary creativity.
What is the dress code at O'Toole's Way?
The dress code is casual, making it a comfortable spot for any occasion.
What payment methods are accepted at O'Toole's Way?
They accept American Express, Apple Pay, MasterCard, and Visa.
Can you recommend nearby places to visit before or after dining at O'Toole's Way?
Guests can enjoy nearby attractions such as The High Line Trail and Hudson Yards, which are excellent for scenic walks and shopping experiences before or after your meal.
Are there convenient transit or ATM options near O'Toole's Way?
Yes, LibertyX Bitcoin ATM is nearby for quick currency exchange, and several convenience stores like Walgreens and Duane Reade are close for other essentials.
What nearby dining options are available around O'Toole's Way?
Nearby restaurants include Oyamel for Mexican cuisine, Leña for Spanish dishes, and Bar Celona, a tapas bar and restaurant, providing diverse dining alternatives.