Customers praised the deliciousness of various menu items, particularly the grilled cheese, burgers, and mac and cheese, while some found certain dishes overly greasy or lacking flavor.
Service
Feedback on service was mixed; many highlighted friendly and attentive staff, while others reported rude interactions and poor service during busy times.
Cleanliness
Several reviews mentioned cleanliness issues, particularly in the bathrooms and food packaging, with some customers reporting unsanitary conditions.
Value for Money
Opinions on pricing varied; some felt the food was reasonably priced for NYC, while others considered it overpriced for the quality received.
Atmosphere
The atmosphere was described as busy and sometimes noisy, which detracted from the dining experience for some customers.
JJ
J J
3 days ago
5.0
They had gluten free bread option. I got that with grilled chicken bacon spicy melt and plain fries.
JG
Juanita G
Nov 14, 2025
3.0
Hello My foodies! I am spending the weekend in NY and stopped by here because we were hungry and it was close by. Well it's definitely a place to go if your hungry, but I wouldn't say it's the best tasting. The burger I got wasn't bad, but it was messy and little greasy. It was ok. The cheese fries unfortunately were cold so the taste was not good. The strawberry drink however was pretty good. Best part of a quick meal. I would only recommend if there is nothing else around and your super hungry! However the service was fine and they were cleaning during our meal so they try to keep it clean.
KK
Kevonart
Nov 12, 2025
5.0
Deliciously good food. They closed a lot of locations but thankfully this one is open still.
BM
Ben Moore
Nov 2, 2025
5.0
Great food and the workers were very nice and attentive. Very much enjoyed and would recommend.
JU
Jair Atusparia Urbina
Oct 31, 2025
1.0
Food is pre cooked and when i got my smokin brisket bun it was frozen inside. They also didnt added the extra guacamole i bought, so i had to wait additional time to have it re-done. Tables were dirty and there was a group of customers that were going behind the counter as they looked friends of the staff (?)
Customer service none existent, but not because of their lack of, more of being short staffed.
Definitely the idea and menu looks tasty, but really needs to be improved
2/10
Yes, you can order online through their website at http://order.meltshop.com/menu/1003-50th-ny.
What payment methods are accepted at Melt Shop?
Melt Shop accepts American Express, Android Pay, Apple Pay, Cash, Mastercard, Samsung Pay, and Visa.
Is Melt Shop wheelchair accessible?
Yes, Melt Shop has a wheelchair accessible entrance.
Does Melt Shop offer vegetarian menu options?
Yes, Melt Shop serves vegetarian food and has options suitable for vegetarians.
What nearby restaurants can I visit before or after Melt Shop?
Nearby restaurants include Sushi & Bento by Mr. Lim - Urban Hawker, Dim Sum Darling, and Bobby Van's steakhouse, offering various dining experiences to complement your visit to Melt Shop.
Are there any nearby bakeries close to Melt Shop?
Yes, Ole & Steen bakery is nearby, perfect for grabbing a pastry or dessert before or after your meal at Melt Shop.
What nearby transit or community services can help visitors find or enjoy the area around Melt Shop?
Visitors can find community services like Volunteers of America - Greater New York nearby, and for travel or accommodation assistance, Fareportal and Camp No Counselors are also close to Melt Shop.