Business Details
About
Italian Restaurant
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.1
1,479 reviews
5 stars
826
4 stars
289
3 stars
152
2 stars
97
1 star
115
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Customers frequently praised the food as delicious, with standout dishes like pasta, pizza, and garlic bread receiving high marks.
Service
Service was generally described as friendly and attentive, though some reviews noted inconsistencies and slower service during busy times.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's cozy and welcoming atmosphere was highlighted, with many customers appreciating the family-owned vibe and decor.
Portion Sizes
While many enjoyed the generous portion sizes, some customers felt that certain dishes were overpriced for the amount served.
Staff Interaction
Staff, including the owner Connie, were often mentioned positively for their warmth and personal engagement with guests.
- ARAlbert RosaNov 8, 20255.0The Chicken Parm was amazing. Definitely trying it again.
- AAAnnieNov 8, 20253.0This restaurant is a stable in Hell's Kitchen. I've decided to stop in with a few of my friends for lunch. I had gone here many times in the past. The Chicken Parmesan was tasteless the extra shrimp rubbery the marinara sauce was so salty. Our server was excellent and the atmosphere was cool Italian. I was very disappointed as I left I walked around the corner to go down the block and saw the B rating on the bottom of a side window.
- NSNathan SelleNov 8, 20255.0Im a tourist and it was exactly what I wanted and a semi stressful day seeing the sights. The atmosphere 🤌the food🤌the service 🤌
- CRCraig RaymondNov 2, 20255.0We had a reservation and had to reschedule due to misunderstanding the play's showtime. They were gracious with our change, and the service and food were excellent.
- TKTra KirkpatrickOct 20, 20255.0Such an underrated restaurant! The food was absolutely fantastic - probably one of the best we’ve had in NYC! Garlic bread to due for. Pizza done just right. Pasta like it was rolled by your grandmother. Tiramisu melted in our mouths. Family owned and operated for over 50 years. Run don’t walk to Mama Mia 44SW!
Frequently Asked Questions About Mama Mia 44SW
What are the regular operating hours of Mama Mia 44SW?
Mama Mia 44SW is open Monday and Tuesday from 4:00 PM to 10:30 PM; Wednesday and Thursday from 12:00 PM to 10:30 PM; Friday and Saturday from 12:00 PM to 11:00 PM; and Sunday from 12:00 PM to 10:30 PM.
Does Mama Mia 44SW provide delivery and in-store pickup services?
Yes, Mama Mia 44SW offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.
What are the takeout hours for Mama Mia 44SW?
Takeout hours match delivery hours: Monday and Tuesday from 4:00 PM to 10:00 PM; Wednesday to Sunday from 12:00 PM to 10:00 PM, with Friday and Saturday until 10:30 PM.
Is Mama Mia 44SW open on major holidays like Christmas or Thanksgiving?
No, Mama Mia 44SW is closed on major holidays including Christmas (December 25) and Thanksgiving (November 27) as specified for multiple years.
What types of cuisine does Mama Mia 44SW specialize in?
Mama Mia 44SW specializes in Italian cuisine including Neapolitan and Southern Italian dishes, with offerings of pizza, pasta, seafood, and vegetarian options.
Where is Mama Mia 44SW located?
Mama Mia 44SW is located at 621 9th Ave, New York, NY 10036, USA.
How can I view Mama Mia 44SW's menu and place an order online?
You can view the menu and place orders at https://mamamia44sw.com/menu.
What are nearby restaurants and dining options close to Mama Mia 44SW?
Nearby dining options include Ari Sushi (sushi), Boon European Bistro (Romanian), Gallo Nero (wine bar), Poppy Poppy (chicken restaurant), and Lazzara's Pizza Cafe (Italian).
Are there any nearby entertainment or drinking spots near Mama Mia 44SW?
Yes, nearby bars and entertainment venues include Gallo Nero wine bar, La Pulperia 44th HK bar, La Faena Social tapas bar, Wine Escape wine bar, and Réunion Surf Bar cocktail bar.
What public transit or services close by could help visitors reach Mama Mia 44SW conveniently?
Nearby services such as 9 Ave & 44 St Corner Cleaners and Western Union can be useful landmarks. The restaurant is centrally located near multiple other restaurants, making transit and exploration convenient for visitors.