Business Details
About
Cupcake Shop
Location
Hours
Reviews
3.8
485 reviews
5 stars
230
4 stars
95
3 stars
48
2 stars
35
1 star
77
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Banana Pudding
The banana pudding is highly praised for its creamy texture and rich flavor, with many customers considering it a must-try.
Service Issues
Numerous reviews highlight inconsistent and often rude service, with some customers reporting negative interactions with staff.
Product Quality
While some desserts are well-received, others, like certain cakes and cupcakes, have been criticized for being dry or stale.
Pricing Concerns
Many customers feel that the prices are high relative to the portion sizes and quality of some items.
Atmosphere
The bakery has a cozy vibe, but the lack of indoor seating and occasional chaotic service detracts from the overall experience.
- ASAhmad Al SbuiNov 17, 20255.0I had a banana pudding here everyday for a whole week
- MMMaelineNov 15, 20255.0I've been here more times than I'd prefer to admit... The cupcakes are consistently a soft but dense cake with balanced icing. I haven't seen anything like the ice box cake at any other bakery nearby, it's great for when you're really craving something sweet. The service has always been good, the workers help everyone promptly and have never messed up my order. Tonight I went and two welcoming gentlemen were working - they were patient in explaining the seasonal cupcake flavors and helpful with choosing which ones to get. I really appreciated the warmth and hospitality, it just goes to show that even with as much traffic as this place sees, they still take good care of their customers.
- CMChristian MaggioNov 4, 20253.0I must say that I left with great enthusiasm, I bought a red velvet (cake not good but very good buttercream), I took a banana pudding but nothing exceptional. The name in this case is not directly proportional to the quality, finally I would say to the saleswomen please a smile you are in New York!
- BWBjoern WirthOct 31, 20254.0Viel Hype um nichts!? Das Ambiente im Laden ist gemütlich und es gibt eine große Auswahl an Gebäck. Preislich liegt die Magnolia Bakery eher im oberen Bereich, die Qualität der Produkte rechtfertigt das aber nicht immer ganz. Der Service ist oft freundlich, aber es gab auch mal unaufmerksame oder gestresste Mitarbeiter, gerade zu Stoßzeiten. Insgesamt: Gute Auswahl, ein berühmter Banana Pudding und nette Atmosphäre, aber manche Produkte sind für meinen Geschmack eher durchschnittlich und zu hochpreisig. Daher solide 3,5 bis 4 Sterne.
- AAAlessandro25Oct 17, 20255.0Dovevo assolutamente provare il banana pudding di Magnolia, e questa sede vicino al mio hotel mi è piaciuta molto: c'è tantissima scelta, i ragazzi sono gentilissimi e sono disponibili anche i cucchiai per l'asporto! Il banana pudding era cremoso, dolce, con pezzi di pan di spagna(credo) all'interno. Davvero ottimo. La carrot cake invece mi è piaciuta di meno, ottimo il frosting ma l'impasto non mi ha convinto. Porzioni enormi, e in totale ho speso 15$ Assolutamente da provare per un turista, Consigliato!
Frequently Asked Questions About Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South
What are the operating hours of Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South?
Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South is open daily from 8:00 AM to 10:00 PM.
Where is Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South located?
It is located at 1794 Broadway, New York, NY 10019, USA.
What type of shop is Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South?
It is a cupcake shop.
Can I find more information about Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South online?
Yes, their website is https://www.magnoliabakery.com/
What is the contact phone number for Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South?
You can reach them at +1 646-908-3838.
Are there any places nearby where I can get ice cream or gelato?
Yes, nearby you can visit Grom or Venchi Chocolate & Gelato for ice cream, gelato, and other desserts.
What nearby places offer tea or coffee if I want to enjoy a drink after my visit to Magnolia Bakery?
Argo Tea is a nearby tea room where you can enjoy a variety of teas.
Are there any sightseeing tour options close to Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South?
Yes, nearby are NYC Pedicab Tours, Central Park Rickshaw Tours, and Official Central Park Horse and Carriage Rides for sightseeing and transportation.
What nearby dining options are available around Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South?
You can find Farinella Pizza Bakery Columbus Circle and Patavini, an Italian restaurant, nearby for more dining options.
Are there any medical or health centers close to Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South?
Yes, there are several including One Medical Primary Care Clinic - 5 Columbus Circle and ColumbiaDoctors with various specialties nearby.