Business Details
About
Cupcake Shop
Location
Hours
Reviews
3.7
509 reviews
5 stars
239
4 stars
102
3 stars
50
2 stars
37
1 star
81
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Banana Pudding
The banana pudding is consistently praised as delicious and a must-try, with many customers expressing their love for its creamy texture and rich flavor.
Service Issues
Numerous reviews highlight poor customer service, with reports of rude staff, unprofessional behavior, and mistakes in orders leading to negative experiences.
Product Quality
While some desserts are well-received, there are complaints about inconsistency in quality, particularly with cupcakes and cakes being described as dry or stale.
Atmosphere
The bakery has a charming atmosphere and is popular among tourists, but some customers noted issues with seating and the overall organization during busy times.
- TTTCP4 days ago5.0Wow if you like sweets you have to go here! My 16 yr old found this and it was packed - a line out the door at 8pm. She had a hard time deciding and had to wait until we got back to hotel to eat it but she gave it 5 stars😋
- JJJessica JonesJan 4, 20261.0My husband loved the banana pudding, however the service was horrendous! The two younger ladies working the cash register and behind the counter were rude at best. Would not suggest a visit to this location if you’re looking for even a crumb of customer service.
- SVShana ValeriDec 27, 20254.0The classic cheesecake as always delicious, the caramel pecan is very good too, just the red velvet is not good. The cream is not tasty and the dough is not well made, you have to improve it.
- MAMohammed ADec 26, 20251.0DO NOT support this location. DO NOT order here!!! They accepted my Uber Eats delivery order 30 minutes before closing. Then, they NEVER prepared the order so it didn’t arrive. It was in “Preparing” for over 45 minutes, even past closing. WHY destroy your business that you built so hard over things like this? This is why so many fail.
- TDTiffany DarstDec 26, 20253.0I purchased a blondie that was one of the best I’ve ever had but the staff in the back was so incredibly rude! She was complaining and ranting in the back and we could hear her the moment we walked in. We could hear her complaining she hated these people and this place and couldn’t wait until she graduated so she could leave nyc. We then ate part of our blondie in the bakery and she spoke to us with a terrible attitude saying we couldn’t eat in there and that we were so rude. We had no idea we couldn’t eat something we bought from the bakery in the bakery. She continued to complain that we weren’t from there and we were so rude. The dessert was so delicious but this staff lady was so incredibly awful I wouldn’t return.
Frequently Asked Questions About Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South
What are the operating hours of Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South?
Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South is open daily from 8:00 AM to 10:00 PM.
Where is Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South located?
It is located at 1794 Broadway, New York, NY 10019, USA.
What type of shop is Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South?
It is a cupcake shop.
Can I find more information about Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South online?
Yes, their website is https://www.magnoliabakery.com/
What is the contact phone number for Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South?
You can reach them at +1 646-908-3838.
Are there any places nearby where I can get ice cream or gelato?
Yes, nearby you can visit Grom or Venchi Chocolate & Gelato for ice cream, gelato, and other desserts.
What nearby places offer tea or coffee if I want to enjoy a drink after my visit to Magnolia Bakery?
Argo Tea is a nearby tea room where you can enjoy a variety of teas.
Are there any sightseeing tour options close to Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South?
Yes, nearby are NYC Pedicab Tours, Central Park Rickshaw Tours, and Official Central Park Horse and Carriage Rides for sightseeing and transportation.
What nearby dining options are available around Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South?
You can find Farinella Pizza Bakery Columbus Circle and Patavini, an Italian restaurant, nearby for more dining options.
Are there any medical or health centers close to Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South?
Yes, there are several including One Medical Primary Care Clinic - 5 Columbus Circle and ColumbiaDoctors with various specialties nearby.