Business Details
About
Pizza RestaurantItalian RestaurantRestaurant Delivery Service
Andrea's Pizza brings authentic, old-school New York-style slices to the heart of the East Village. Founded by veteran pizzaiolo Andrea Kenuti, formerly of Scarrs Pizza and L'Industrie, the pizzeria opened its doors at 50 2nd Ave in July 2025. Every thin-crusted pie is hand-tossed, lightly charred, and topped with perfectly balanced tomato sauce and melty, salty cheese, earning rave reviews from local tastemakers. With cozy indoor booths, outdoor tables, and delivery rolling out soon, Andrea's blends nostalgic flavor with a modern, neighborhood vibe. Stop in noon to midnight daily (extended weekend hours) for the kind of slice that keeps East Villagers and visitors coming back for more.
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.9
85 reviews
5 stars
79
4 stars
3
3 stars1
2 stars1
1 star1
- SSSara Soto2 days ago5.0Best thing to happen to this neighborhood— the most delicious pizza!! Thank you, Andrea.
- JLJoon Lee3 days ago5.0Both the regular and Sicilian slices are top notch. You can taste how the dough is in the lineage of Scarrs and L’Industrie. One of the best new slice shops in the city!
- MKM KNov 16, 20255.0Great slice! The dough was really well developed. Had great chew. I personally wish it had sliiiighly less cheese (which I know isn’t an issue for some people!) otherwise this was top level. Staff were friendly and welcoming. Service was great. Shop was clean.
- CLCharlene Auriel LimNov 15, 20254.0Love the vodka pesto slice, but the cheese slice was kind of average
- MJMartin Lang JrOct 31, 20251.0I came in here on Halloween with my brother for the first time excited to try the neighborhood pizza. Pizza looked good so I grabbed two pepperoni slices. There was a tall man with a beard with an attitude off the bat. After we ordered our food we asked that we get it to go in a box. He proceeded to put the food in a bag. We thought he didn’t hear us so we asked again, kindly. He proceeded to put our food in bags. We asked a third time and he visibly scoffed, and threw boxes on the counter to box it up ourselves, as if it was an inconvenience for him. I am not sure if this behavior was due to our race as we are both black men, but I’ve never experienced such hostility while simply trying to order a slice of pizza. As for the food, the pizza was cold but it wasn’t bad. Overall, don’t recommend eating here if you’re a person of color, especially if the bearded man is working.
Frequently Asked Questions About Andrea's Pizza
What kind of pizza does Andrea’s Pizza serve?
What kind of pizza does Andrea’s Pizza serve?
Do you offer pizza by the slice?
Yes! We’re known for our fresh, ready-to-go slices — perfect for a quick lunch or late-night craving.
Where is Andrea’s Pizza located?
You’ll find us at 50 2nd Ave in the heart of the East Village, Manhattan — just steps from St. Mark’s Place.
Do you offer delivery?
Yes, we offer delivery through apps like Slice, Uber Eats, and DoorDash. You can also order directly from our website.
Can I order online for pickup?
Absolutely. Order online through our website for fast and easy pickup.
Are you open late?
Yes! We’re open until midnight on weekdays and until 2 AM on Fridays and Saturdays.
Do you have vegetarian options?
Yes, many of our pizzas — including cheese, Margherita, and Grandma slices — are vegetarian-friendly.
Do you offer gluten-free crust?
Not at the moment, but we’re always working on new options. Check back soon or ask our staff.
Do you serve anything besides pizza?
Yes — we’ve got calzones, garlic knots, and rotating specials to go with your slice.
Where is Andrea’s Pizza located?
Andrea’s Pizza is located at 50 2nd Ave in the East Village neighborhood of Manhattan, New York.
What are the opening hours of Andrea’s Pizza?
Andrea’s Pizza is open from noon to midnight Monday through Thursday, until 2 AM on Fridays and Saturdays, and until 11 PM on Sundays.
Does Andrea’s Pizza accept reservations?
No, Andrea’s Pizza does not accept reservations; they operate on a walk-in and order basis.
Does Andrea’s Pizza offer delivery and pickup services?
Yes, Andrea’s Pizza offers in-store pickup, curbside pickup, delivery, same-day delivery, and no-contact delivery.
Can I order Andrea’s Pizza online?
Yes, you can order online for pickup or delivery through their website or via delivery apps like Slice, Uber Eats, and DoorDash.
What types of pizza and other food items does Andrea’s Pizza offer?
They serve New York-style pizzas including Sicilian, Grandma, Margherita, cheese, pepperoni, and daily specials, along with calzones and garlic knots.
Does Andrea’s Pizza offer vegetarian or gluten-free options?
There are several vegetarian pizza options like cheese and Margherita, but gluten-free crust is not currently available.
What payment options does Andrea’s Pizza accept?
They accept various payment methods including American Express, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Mastercard, Visa, cash, and contactless payments.
What nearby establishments can customers visit around Andrea's Pizza?
Nearby places include FRED.nyc (a hair and beauty salon), Happy Massage New York (a spa and massage center), and Pak Punjab Deli & Grocery (a deli and grocery store). Customers might visit these before or after enjoying pizza at Andrea’s.
Are there other pizza places near Andrea’s Pizza?
Yes, nearby pizza restaurants include Proto’s Pizza and Il Gusto Pizza, offering alternatives if you want to explore different pizza options in the East Village area.
What local attractions or points of interest are near Andrea’s Pizza?
Andrea’s Pizza is near St. Mark’s Place and NYU. Visitors can enjoy shopping and entertainment on St. Mark’s Place or explore the NYU campus before or after their meal.