16 Handles is a dessert shop offering a rotating menu of Artisan frozen yogurt, ice cream, vegan soft serve, and other treats plus an endless toppings bar.
Customers appreciate the wide selection of flavors and toppings available, although some noted inconsistencies in flavor quality.
Cleanliness Issues
Multiple reviews highlighted concerns about cleanliness, including sticky floors and strong cleaning chemical odors.
Customer Service
Feedback on staff behavior was mixed; while some praised friendly and helpful employees, others reported rude or unprofessional interactions.
Pricing Concerns
Many customers felt the prices were high relative to the quality and portion sizes, with some expressing dissatisfaction over unclear pricing.
SO
Saoni O'Donnell
Dec 2, 2025
5.0
The Gingerbread ice cream was delicious
NN
Nam
Sep 10, 2025
1.0
This place always smells intensely of cleaning liquid and bleach. It feels weird for the froyo to be constantly exposed to such intense chemicals. I also worry about whether the food and food prep comes in contact with this cleaning liquid. They had kept the bottle of liquid (spray) right next to the napkins. I don't know why such a heavy dose of cleaning is required.
MD
Michela Demelas
Sep 9, 2025
4.0
I’m celiac and lactose intolerant. I like that they have good options for me. The oatmilk-based yogurt is very good. I’ve been going there since they stopped using Oatly, which I boycott (BDS). Good choices for toppings too.
RR
Roy
Jul 19, 2025
4.0
The frozen yogurt was nice, but everything, especially the floor was sticky, and it was pretty expensive.
16 Handles offers a rotating menu of artisan frozen yogurt, ice cream, vegan soft serve, and other treats, plus an endless toppings bar.
What are the operating hours of 16 Handles on weekdays?
16 Handles is open from 12:00 PM to 10:00 PM Monday through Wednesday, and from 12:00 PM to 11:00 PM on Thursday and Friday.
Is 16 Handles wheelchair accessible?
Yes, 16 Handles has a wheelchair-accessible entrance.
What payment methods are accepted at 16 Handles?
16 Handles accepts American Express, Apple Pay, Cash, Discover, Mastercard, Samsung Pay, and Visa.
Can I order from 16 Handles online?
Yes, you can place your order online at https://orders.16handles.com/order-type.
How can I contact 16 Handles via email?
You can email 16 Handles at uws@16handles.com for inquiries.
Which nearby bakery would be a good place to visit before or after 16 Handles?
Crumbs is a nearby bakery that you might enjoy visiting before or after your dessert at 16 Handles.
Are there any nearby restaurants where I can have a meal before trying dessert at 16 Handles?
Yes, nearby restaurants include Citrus Bar & Grill (Asian cuisine), 'Cesca (Italian restaurant), Playa Betty’s (Mexican and American food with a bar), and Benny's N Y (Mexican restaurant).
What nearby fitness and wellness venues are close to 16 Handles?
Nearby you can find NYC Pilates, a pilates studio and gym for sports and recreation, as well as the JCC Health Club gym.
Where can I find community and cultural activities near 16 Handles?
Nearby community and cultural venues include JCC Manhattan for community services and cinema, Israel Film Center for cinema and community activities, and Art Studios @ JCC in Manhattan offering art gallery and concert events.