Customers consistently praised the food quality, highlighting dishes like pizza, pasta, and specialty items as delicious and well-prepared.
Service Issues
Several reviews noted poor service experiences, including rude staff and issues with order accuracy, particularly at the takeout counter.
Atmosphere
The restaurant is described as clean and welcoming, with some positive mentions of the ambiance and friendly staff, although experiences varied.
Pricing Concerns
Some customers expressed dissatisfaction with pricing, feeling that the cost of food was high relative to the portion sizes and service received.
AG
A G
Jan 5, 2026
5.0
Food is delicious, service is good, a little too bright but nice atmosphere.
KD
Kieko D.
Dec 31, 2025
1.0
Good food. Horrible service. Went there and they made me feel like I didnt belong there. I've gone a few times and I thought it was me or maybe they were having a bad day but definitely it was me being there. This time I walked in, ordered my food and 3 other people ordered food after me and my food only went in the oven after they left and it was only a couple of slices. Unfortunately I wont be going there anymore. Even though the food is good not worth feeling like me being who I was is the reason I have to wait longer then anyone else.
TB
Tenia Bryson
Dec 26, 2025
1.0
Food good but service is horrible. They hang up on customers, pick up the phone and put it on hold without saying anything and rude when you do finally get a person.
MR
Matt Rivera
Dec 18, 2025
5.0
Whether I show up at the restaurant or I order it for delivery the food quality is always the same. It’s phenomenal. It always is hot and it tastes good. Never had an issue there. It’s my number one go to
Spot for shrimp farm heroes & eggplant rollatini.
LM
Larry Marshall
Dec 14, 2025
5.0
Ordered dinner to go for the family on Friday( Mary’s Combo, Chicken Parm, Spaghetti & Meatballs and salad with mixed greens and pizza. Amazing!!!
Everything was fresh and delicious. Great portions. Thanks for a wonderful dining experience. We will be back👍🏼👍🏼
Frequently Asked Questions About Mary's Pizza and Pasta
What type of cuisine does Mary's Pizza and Pasta offer?
Mary's Pizza and Pasta offers authentic Italian cuisine in a warm atmosphere.
Where is Mary's Pizza and Pasta located?
It is located at 876 Connetquot Avenue, Islip Terrace, NY 11752, United States.
What are the opening hours of Mary's Pizza and Pasta?
Mary's Pizza and Pasta is open Monday through Thursday and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 9:30 PM; Fridays and Saturdays from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM.
Can I view the menu for Mary's Pizza and Pasta online?
Yes, you can view the menu online at https://maryspizzaandpasta.com/farmingdale-dineinmenu/.
Is it possible to place an order online at Mary's Pizza and Pasta?
Yes, you can place an order online at https://maryspizza.hungerrush.com/Order/OrderType.
What are some nearby places to visit before or after dining at Mary's Pizza and Pasta?
Nearby places include Scoops & Sprinkles ice cream shop, Jade Garden restaurant, and Terrace Bagelry & Deli, which are great options for dessert or other meals.
Are there any grocery stores close to Mary's Pizza and Pasta for convenient shopping?
Yes, nearby supermarkets include Fair Trade Market, Akal Supermarket, and Emporium Fresh Market of Islip for your grocery needs.
Where can I find fitness or wellness centers near Mary's Pizza and Pasta?
Results Fitness gym and Bushido Karate Dojo are nearby, perfect if you'd like to work out before or after your meal.
Does Mary's Pizza and Pasta have a presence on social media?
Yes, you can find them on Facebook at https://www.facebook.com/372087066747557.
What categories best describe Mary's Pizza and Pasta?
Mary's Pizza and Pasta is categorized as a pizza restaurant and an Italian restaurant.