Mary's Pizza and Pasta

4.5
1144 reviews
Get DirectionsCallWebsite

Business Details

876 Connetquot Avenue, Islip Terrace, NY
11752, United States
(631) 277-1590
https://maryspizzaandpasta.com/
GoogleFacebook

About

Pizza RestaurantItalian Restaurant
Come in and enjoy fine dining and real authentic Italian cuisine in a warm atmosphere at our restaurant.

Location

Mary's Pizza and Pasta
876 Connetquot Avenue, Islip Terrace, NY
11752, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.5
1,144 reviews
5 stars
786
4 stars
240
3 stars
51
2 stars
30
1 star
37

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Food Quality

Customers consistently praised the food, especially the pizza and pasta dishes, noting the delicious flavors and quality ingredients.

Service Issues

While many reviews highlighted excellent service, there were notable complaints about inconsistent service and rude staff at times.

Pricing Concerns

Several customers expressed dissatisfaction with rising prices and perceived value, feeling that the quality had declined relative to the cost.

Cleanliness

The establishment is frequently described as clean and well-maintained, contributing positively to the dining experience.

Customer Loyalty

Many long-time customers expressed strong loyalty to the restaurant, often returning for years and recommending it to others.
  • NT
    Nancy T
    Nov 4, 2025
    5.0
    Get it while you can! Ordered the butternut squash ravioli and it was by far the best I have ever had! I would have licked the bowl if that would have been acceptable lol Everything from the food to the service was exceptional! A great evening out
  • CS
    Chris Senti
    Nov 4, 2025
    5.0
    Pizza was great although a bit greasy. Philly sandwich was good too
  • ER
    Estela Rodriguez
    Oct 29, 2025
    5.0
    Alla vodka anything....wow
  • SG
    Steve Guz
    Oct 25, 2025
    5.0
    Very good, a step above any othe pizzeria around
  • MG
    Mg G
    Oct 4, 2025
    2.0
    Loved the food, I moved out of state and miss the NY pizza. In town visiting family. However, I was taken aback when I got an alert this morning from my bank asking if I had left a 41% tip. My bill was $23.92 for 2 slices of pizza and a takeout baked Ziti. I did not have table service. I specifically asked if I needed to wait to be seated as I have never been to this restaurant before, it was recommended . The gentleman asked me what was I getting, I said 2 slices and a baked ziti to go. He looked around and said no I could sit anywhere and pay at the counter. That's what I did. I paid at the counter, gave the gentleman my card, and he rung it up. He brought out the 2 slices as we waited for the ziti. I was not given the opportunity to pick how much tip I was giving, if any. I thought the amount of $33.65 was a bit high but didn't look over the bill as I was tending to my grandson. It wasn't until I received the alert from my bank that I was made aware that I had even left a tip. Had they given me the opportunity to leave a tip, I would have. But to take the liberty of doing it for me, and 41 % at that, that's not cool. I have contacted my bank in regards. Very dissapointing. Other than that the food is great. I would've given 5 stars if not for this.
Read more reviews on Google

Frequently Asked Questions About Mary's Pizza and Pasta

What type of cuisine does Mary's Pizza and Pasta offer?

Mary's Pizza and Pasta offers authentic Italian cuisine in a warm atmosphere.

Where is Mary's Pizza and Pasta located?

It is located at 876 Connetquot Avenue, Islip Terrace, NY 11752, United States.