Customers consistently praised the attentive and friendly service from staff, particularly highlighting servers like Kastro and Rachel.
Food Quality
The food received high marks for taste and variety, with specific mentions of dishes like the fig and goat cheese pizza, burgers, and French dip.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's ambiance was frequently described as cozy and welcoming, with live music enhancing the dining experience.
Customer Loyalty
Many reviews indicated that customers are repeat visitors, often returning for the quality of food and service.
Mixed Experiences
While most feedback was positive, a few customers reported issues with food quality and service inconsistencies.
TP
Tara Pisano
Nov 14, 2025
5.0
From Jersey. Been following this place for a while on social media, wanting to come here, and tonight had the chance to finally make it in. It did NOT disappoint! Exceedingly clean. Everyone was super nice. Manager Dawn purposely made her way to our table to say hello and strike up conversation. Sent the owner Marc over who was just as nice and offered a dessert/drink on him. Wish we lived closer as this would be our weekly place. We will be back for sure! Food was excellent. Drinks were great. HIGHLY recommend you stop in if you’re in the area!! We are 40 mins away and we’ll come back as often as we can! GO!!
MP
Millie Pagan
Nov 8, 2025
5.0
The food is amazing. The atmosphere is very friendly and our server Rachel is super awesome and very attentive. We always ask for her she’s the best.
MS
Maria Gagliano (Maria's Space)
Nov 8, 2025
5.0
Great food! Honestly very surprised that I had never heard about this place but when a friend suggested it was happy to give it a try.
The service was amazing. Friendly and funny. Accommodated our long friendship lunch without making us feel rushed or pressured to order or leave.
Had the lobster roll which while smaller that other places was filled with more lobster than I’ve ever had in other places. Very tasty.
Fries were really good.
Got the coconut shrimp and calamari which didn’t disappoint.
One friend had 28 barrel burger which I will order next time. Very yummy.
Had a mocktail so I looked like I was drinking with the big girls which I could go for right now!!
CM
Corgi M
Nov 2, 2025
5.0
I have been here numerous times over a few years. With the exception of 1 bad experience with poor service, we always enjoyed it here. The menu has a good selection and the food is great- the clams appetizer is out of this world. It's also a great bar spot late night- live music, large beer selection, good prices, and a generous staff
KW
Kristen Warfield
Nov 2, 2025
5.0
We love going to Barrel 28! Went last night and ordered the Autumn Ravioli special which was amazing— my man ordered the lobster roll and he really enjoyed it. The food is great, they have a friendly staff, and the live music on Saturdays is super fun. Thanks for being a great date night out for us!
- Kristen and Fabian
What are the opening hours of Barrel 28 for dine-in service?
Barrel 28 is open from 12:00 PM to 9:00 PM Tuesday to Thursday and Sunday, and from 12:00 PM to 1:00 AM on Friday and Saturday. It is closed on Mondays.
Is Barrel 28 open for takeout and delivery?
Yes, Barrel 28 offers both takeout and delivery services with hours from 12:00 PM to 8:40 PM Tuesday to Thursday and Sunday, and until 9:40 PM on Friday and Saturday. It is closed on Mondays.
Does Barrel 28 provide in-store pickup options?
Yes, Barrel 28 offers in-store pickup along with delivery services.
Where is Barrel 28 located?
Barrel 28 is located at 28 N Main St, Florida, NY 10921, USA.
What types of cuisine can I expect at Barrel 28?
Barrel 28 serves a variety of cuisines including American, Italian, pizza, hamburgers, seafood, brunch options, and vegetarian dishes.
What is the price range at Barrel 28?
Barrel 28 falls into the mid-range pricing category represented as 'TWO'.
Can I view the menu and place an order online for Barrel 28?
Yes, you can view the menu and place orders online at https://barrel28.com/menu.
Are there any nearby bars where I can visit before or after dining at Barrel 28?
Yes, nearby bars include Logan's Well, The Sweet Onion Brewhouse, Slattery's Florida Bar & Grill, and Mattingly's Tavern, which you might want to check out for drinks or socializing.
What nearby shops and services are available close to Barrel 28?
Nearby you can find various shops and services such as The Eclectic Eye & Company (antique store), RepairIT Solutions (IT service), TradeIT (electronics and video games), and Farmbody Skin Care (beauty and cosmetic supplies).
Is there a nearby ATM or banking service close to Barrel 28?
Yes, the LibertyX Bitcoin ATM is located nearby for your convenience with ATM and banking services.