Business Details
About
Grocery StoreGourmet Grocery StoreSeafood MarketProduce Market
Stock your home with gourmet essentials: Citarella is the perfect place to find everything you need for an extraordinary meal. We offer a stunning variety of fresh seafood, prime meats, carefully curated produce, artisanal cheeses, fresh pastas, chef-prepared dishes, handcrafted pastries, and more.
This location features:
• Personal Shopping, featuring In-Store Pick-Up | 631-283-6600
• Salad Bar, Hot Bar & Soups
• Brick-Oven Pizza
• On-Site Sushi Chefs
• To-Go Counter
• Indoor/Outdoor Seating Area
• Gourmet Gift Baskets
• In-Store Tastings
• Floral
• Coffee Bar
Details
- DebitNot available
- Mobile paymentsNot available
- Accepts checksNot available
- Wheelchair accessible entranceAvailable
Location
Citarella Gourmet Market - Bridgehampton
2209 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton, NY
11932, United States
Hours
Reviews
4.3
466 reviews
5 stars
271
4 stars
109
3 stars
53
2 stars
16
1 star
17
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Quality Concerns
Several customers expressed disappointment with the quality of certain food items, particularly prepared foods and specific menu items like pizza and chicken.
Pricing
Many reviews noted that the prices are high, with some customers feeling that the quality does not justify the cost.
Customer Service
Feedback on staff interactions was mixed; while some praised the helpfulness and friendliness of staff, others reported negative experiences, including poor service and language assumptions.
Product Selection
Customers appreciated the wide variety of gourmet and specialty food items available, including fresh produce, seafood, and prepared meals.
Cleanliness and Organization
The store was frequently described as clean and well-organized, contributing positively to the shopping experience.
- JJJOct 3, 20251.0Purchased a sirloin steak for a total of $79.00 and it was disgusting, fatty and just not what was expected from such a gourmet market. Don't mind paying for good but expect quality to substantiate the pricing structure. Very disappointing.
- JJjjSep 2, 20254.0Amazing selections, great on the go food for the beach. Pretty busy but manageable to get in and out fairly quickly if you know what you want. Overpriced but it’s Citarella in the Hamptons, what do you expect. Overall will always come back here for a nice treat.
- LKLynette KamimuraAug 14, 20255.0One of our favorite markets in the Hamptons for great fresh, organic produce, curated natural snacks, and good to-go food. I'm vegan/plant-based and the vegetable sushi rolls are a nice option for lunch on the go or a beach picnic
- RARafael AlmanzarMay 18, 20195.0Perfect
Frequently Asked Questions About Citarella Gourmet Market - Bridgehampton
What are the regular operating hours of Citarella Gourmet Market in Bridgehampton?
Citarella Gourmet Market in Bridgehampton is open daily from 7:00 AM to 7:30 PM.
Are there special shopping hours for seniors and disabled individuals?
Yes, the first hour from 8:00 AM to 9:00 AM is dedicated to seniors and disabled shoppers to provide a comfortable shopping experience.
What types of products can I find at Citarella Gourmet Market in Bridgehampton?
At Citarella, you can find fresh seafood, prime meats, curated produce, artisanal cheeses, fresh pastas, chef-prepared dishes, handcrafted pastries, gourmet gift baskets, floral items, and coffee.
Does Citarella Bridgehampton offer any prepared food options on-site?
Yes, the location features a hot bar, soups, a brick-oven pizza station, on-site sushi chefs, a to-go counter, and indoor/outdoor seating for dining.
Is Citarella Bridgehampton accessible for people with disabilities?
Yes, the market has wheelchair accessible entrances and parking, making it accessible for customers with disabilities.
What payment methods are accepted at Citarella Gourmet Market in Bridgehampton?
Citarella accepts American Express, Cash, Check, Discover, MasterCard, and Visa as payment options.
Is there public restroom availability at Citarella Bridgehampton?
Yes, there are public restrooms available for customers at Citarella Bridgehampton.
Are there any nearby banking options near Citarella Bridgehampton?
Yes, nearby banks include Dime Community Bank, Bridgehampton National Bank, and several insurance agencies such as Hamptons Risk Management Insurance Agency and Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company.
What nearby dining and food establishments can I visit when shopping at Citarella?
Nearby dining options include Carvel for ice cream, Just Food For Dogs for pets and food, and the Bridgehampton Inn & Restaurant for American cuisine and lodging.
Are there any fitness or wellness centers near Citarella Gourmet Market?
Yes, fitness and wellness centers nearby include Physique 57 - Bridgehampton Studio and Bridgehampton Pilates, offering active life and health services.