Customers consistently praised the food for being fresh, flavorful, and well-prepared, with many highlighting specific dishes as exceptional.
Service
The staff received numerous compliments for being friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable, enhancing the overall dining experience.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's ambiance was frequently described as clean, inviting, and beautifully decorated, contributing positively to customer experiences.
Portion Sizes
Several reviews mentioned concerns about small portion sizes relative to the prices, with some customers expressing disappointment over value for money.
Pricing
While many found the prices reasonable for the quality, others felt that the cost was high for the portion sizes offered.
CS
Carol Speck
Jan 13, 2026
5.0
Wow! What an exceptional experience and meal. Never having gone to an Indian Restaurant, our waiter was very kind and guided our choices. The Samosa was very tasty, especially when the two dipping sauces were combined. Our entree was — Dum Ka Murgh with a Naan stuffed with potato and peas. The most delicious food, I could not finish my meal, although I really wanted to, and had to bring some home, it was just as good for lunch the next day!
The restaurant itself is beautiful. The wine list and cocktail choices are varried and there is something for everyone! So glad to have dined here. We will be back!
CC
Cat Chez
Jan 12, 2026
5.0
I was never a fan on Indian food but I am now!! So lucky to have a great restaurant in our area.
Can’t believe I haven’t already reviewed.
Tonight we’re having their take out. We love eating there as well, service with smile, no long waits. Just an awesome experience all around.
Yay.
DS
Damien Stavar
Jan 3, 2026
5.0
I went there with my 3 boys. One who is a huge fan of the food. Another just getting into it and a third who lightly treads. The buffet was fresh. Tastefully planned and had many options. We were able to get in, eat and get out in a reasonable amount of time. Very good job. So happy we have a reasonably priced resteraunt near our house.
CM
Conrad McLean
Dec 30, 2025
5.0
Stumbled across Indian Spice and so glad we did. The food was absolutely excellent. Fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. What really made the experience stand out, though, was the service. Clive was welcoming, attentive, and genuinely made us feel at home. Great food, even better hospitality. We’ll definitely be back!
NC
Nicholas Chiappini
Dec 22, 2025
5.0
As a Sussex county kid, I was so excited to see this place on the map while up visiting my parents. Blew my expectations clean out do the water, just delicious food, extremely reasonable prices and a huge variety of dishes for palates new to Indian cuisine and those that know and love it.
The lunch special is a great entry point ($15) offering an appetizer (samosa), a main, naan and some dal.
Will definitely be a frequent visit for me whenever back home!
Frequently Asked Questions About Indian Spice Route 23
What are the opening hours of Indian Spice Route 23?
Indian Spice Route 23 is open from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM Monday and Wednesday through Sunday. It is closed on Tuesdays.
Where is Indian Spice Route 23 located?
It is located at 455 Route 23, Suite 1, North Wantage, NJ 07461, United States.
What type of cuisine does Indian Spice Route 23 serve?
Indian Spice Route 23 serves Indian cuisine as an Indian restaurant.
How can I contact Indian Spice Route 23?
You can call Indian Spice Route 23 at +1 973-298-0252 for reservations or inquiries.
Does Indian Spice Route 23 have a social media presence?
Yes, Indian Spice Route 23 has a Facebook page available at https://www.facebook.com/695544853634790.
Are there any gyms nearby Indian Spice Route 23?
Yes, Snap Fitness - Wantage, NJ is a nearby gym where you can work out before or after visiting Indian Spice Route 23.
What other dining options are close to Indian Spice Route 23?
Nearby dining options include Brothers Pizza & Italian Restaurant, Eastern Garden (Chinese and Japanese cuisine), Friendly's (American restaurant and ice cream), and MrBeast Burger.
Are there any services near Indian Spice Route 23 for banking or postal needs?
Yes, Lakeland Bank and several post office locations including US Post Office and United States Postal Service are near Indian Spice Route 23 for your banking and mailing needs.
Where can I shop for groceries close to Indian Spice Route 23?
You can visit ACME Markets or ShopRite of Sussex nearby for groceries, bakery items, and pharmacy needs.
Are there any automotive services near Indian Spice Route 23?
Yes, sites like Tire King, Franklin Sussex Hyundai, and Hyundai car dealers are near Indian Spice Route 23 for tire, automotive repair, and new car purchases.