Multiple customers reported issues with incorrect orders and missing items, leading to dissatisfaction.
Food Quality
While some praised the pizza and other menu items, many reviews noted bland flavors and poor quality in certain dishes.
Service Experience
Customer service experiences varied, with some staff being friendly while others were reported as rude or unhelpful.
Cleanliness
Several reviews mentioned cleanliness issues, including unsanitary conditions and poor food handling practices.
Convenience
The 24-hour availability of the eatery was frequently highlighted as a major advantage for late-night diners.
DM
David Magadan
Jan 4, 2026
2.0
Expected a little bit more out of a 30 dollar pie than overly sweet sauce and jar-lic just slapped on there.
LO
Leo Ocasio
Dec 31, 2025
1.0
the food has no taste to it and cold
LB
Lauren Brackett
Dec 29, 2025
1.0
Ordered off DoorDash yesterday, asked for a honey turkey and cheese with mayo HOT, with fettuccine Alfredo, instead of reaching out they gave me two cold sandwiches with lettuce and tomato. And now DoorDash won’t issue a refund. If this store can give me my money back I won’t complain but if I have to dispute the charge I’m gonna have to report. Got my whole damn order wrong couldn’t even eat anything.
JJ
Jesse Janson
Dec 25, 2025
3.0
I eat at Stella’s all the time and I love their food! This particular night I thought I’d get delivery as I wasn’t beat to drive at 3am.
I ordered 4 slices total and not a single slice was correct. 2 slices of bbq chicken which when it arrived was a buffalo chicken and ranch slice and some sort of veggie slice.
The other 2 were bacon chicken bacon and ranch with added mushrooms. There were no added mushrooms to the pizza.
100% will never order delivery from them again! Will 100% eat there eventually just not anytime soon.
GG
Greg
Nov 26, 2025
5.0
I had eaten food from Stella's before and was please with the food I purchased. However I was extremely impressed withy current order. I ordered a slice of pizza and fettuccini Alfredo. YUM I KNOW!
The pizza was typical yet the taste was amazing. I am not sure if the shell is made fresh or frozen, but when fresh or frozen, they have made a good choice.
The fettuccini Alfredo was just as good!
The only issue I have is that when you call there to ask to see if they a certain item the woman who answers the calls does not answer kindly but gets annoyed and hands up.
Otherwise, good job Stells and the chefs that make this place wonderful.