Efi's Gyro

Reviews

• CD

  Chanty D

  Nov 3, 2025
  5.0
  Atmosphere is so peaceful and clean , visually a very nice aesthetic. Food was delicious , had the lamb kabob bowl with add ons that were superbly seasoned really very exceptionally tasty food. The falafel was freshly made, so warm, truly the best I've had in years! Their touches to the food add warmth and coziness to your meal the pita is seasoned and with a drizzle of olive oil , both such soft and crunchy elements to it , and a nice presentation.., delectable served to perfection!! Than there are the employees, Nikolaos' customer service alone is what would bring you back time and time again. I for sure am visiting soon , maybe tomorrow :) such a heartwarming , kind , compassionate person he named so many customers in greeting and departure. One was pleasantly surprised his name was remembered. Nikolaos surely is an outstanding individual very friendly disposition and accommodating in placing our order. We thought he was the owner, his service skills will get him so far in life. God bless him and the employees and the establishment. Thank you for everything Nikolaos keep smiling ☺️🩵🤍
• YL

  Yi Lee

  Nov 2, 2025
  5.0
  Absolutely delicious! Efi’s Gyro is hands down one of the best Greek spots around. The gyros are packed with perfectly seasoned meat, fresh veggies, and that creamy, flavorful tzatziki sauce that ties it all together. Everything tastes authentic and freshly made — you can really tell they care about quality. The staff are super friendly and make you feel welcome the moment you walk in. Service is quick, portions are generous, and the prices are very reasonable for how much food you get. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or sitting down for dinner, Efi’s Gyro never disappoints. Highly recommend the lamb gyro and the fries — absolutely amazing! I’ll definitely be coming back again and again.
• IP

  Inri Panajoti

  Oct 25, 2025
  5.0
  The best gyro ever! The meat is incredibly juicy and tender, and some of the best fries I’ve ever had. Every bite is packed with flavor. On top of that, the owner is super nice and welcoming, which makes the whole experience even better. You can really feel how much pride they take in their food and service. Highly recommend to anyone who loves great gyros because this is my go to spot several times a week!
• SC

  Swamp Cat

  Oct 25, 2025
  1.0
  I've eaten here 3 times i must not know how to order. I just want a gyro but I keep getting French fries and a ton of onions and brown sauce. I want lettuce and tomato and tzatziki and meat. Not impressed with fries on the thing and a ton of red onions gross. Never again. I know what a gyro is suppose to be and this ain't it.
• JL

  Jacob Lombardi

  Oct 13, 2025
  5.0
  ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Efi’s is the best authentic Greek & Mediterranean cuisine in New Jersey—hands down. Their menu hits every note: gyros, souvlaki, falafel, salads, and housemade dips that deliver bold, fresh flavor. • Signature dishes: Chicken gyro, beef & lamb gyro, grilled lamb souvlaki, and build-your-own bowls • Quality ingredients: USDA-inspected meats, fresh produce, and imported Greek staples like feta, olive oil, and pita • Clean cooking: No gluten, MSG, preservatives, or antibiotics in their meats Efi’s deserves recognition for making THE BEST TZATZIKI in North America, never mind New Jersey. This establishment deserves a Michelin Bib Gourmand award for their exceptional food and service. The staff is welcoming, and genuinely committed to making every visit memorable. As for the owner, Stephano—his commitment to customer service blew me away. I placed a late dinner order and ran to CVS before it arrived. When I got home, I found two full orders. I hadn’t been charged twice, so I called to clarify. Stephano explained he was worried about the Uber driver’s timing and personally sent a second order with his own driver to ensure I’d be taken care of. That’s not just good service—it’s elite. Whether you’re grabbing lunch or catering for a crowd, Efi’s delivers Michelin-grade hospitality and flavor. I imagine Heaven being an all you can eat buffet with Efi’s catering and never ending supply of Efis homemade tzatziki. Efis isn’t just a gyro shop—it’s a taste of home and heaven.

Frequently Asked Questions About Efi's Gyro