Business Details
About
Italian RestaurantRestaurantPizza RestaurantFine Dining RestaurantFamily Style Restaurant
For over five decades, Bartolino’s has been a cornerstone of St. Louis’s renowned Italian neighborhood, The Hill, embodying our community’s rich traditions and heritage. Our newly renovated space blends modern elegance with timeless charm, providing an inviting backdrop to savor the authentic Italian cuisine we’ve become known for.
True to our motto—”Cook good food & give plenty. Basta!”—Bartolino’s The Hill is dedicated to delivering exceptional dishes and impeccable service, ensuring every visit is a satisfying and memorable experience.
Details
- Dine-inAvailable
- DeliveryAvailable
- TakeoutAvailable
- Accepts reservationsAvailable
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.4
1,046 reviews
5 stars
718
4 stars
159
3 stars
67
2 stars
33
1 star
69
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Service Issues
Customers frequently reported slow service, especially during busy times, leading to frustration.
Food Quality
Mixed reviews on food quality; while some dishes were praised, others were criticized for being bland or poorly prepared.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's atmosphere received positive feedback for being inviting and lively, though some found it too loud.
Customer Experience
Several reviews highlighted poor customer service experiences, particularly regarding management's handling of complaints.
Value for Money
Many customers felt the prices were high relative to the quality of food and service received.
- EBE Blair2 days ago1.0The pasta arrived less al dente and more lost at sea. If this was linguini, it was linguini in witness protection… submerged in so much liquid it should’ve come with a lifeguard and a whistle. The salad…. Brown lettuce that looked like it had seen some things and didn’t care to talk about them. Now here’s the real punchline: one soup water pasta and one exhausted salad came to nearly $100. For that price, I got soggy noodles and produce that had clearly given up on life. If this is Italian dining, then I’m Sophia Petrillo ready for Shady Pines itself.
- EBElizabeth B2 days ago1.0Disgusting. Shame on them for charging $28 for a pasta plate. DISGUSTING. STAY AWAY. You think you’re ordering nice cuisine…. You’re not. It’s water soup. I will fight this cried card charge
- CCCaseyJan 4, 20265.0Great lunch experience. Delicious food. Great prices. Staff was extremely nice in making our kids feel comfortable. Pizza was good. Pasta was good. Great place.
- DTDave ThompsonDec 24, 20251.0This experience was extremely disappointing and not as advertised. We expected a nice dinner that was so far from what we received. First, the wait was horrible. We had reservations and we were seated late. The atmosphere was awkward and loud. We waited for almost 3 hours for our food. We weren’t provided utensils and the appetizers were bland and stale. We paid a dumb amount of money for the appetizers. We never even got a full meal. The fact that we are putting energy into this review is honestly disheartening, but we have to warn people to not waste their money.
- TTTJJDec 21, 20253.0This is an interesting place. Located in a mall. We arrived and the restaurant was packed. Yet during our meal the place cleared out fast and we practically closed the place down. I had the chicken Parm,. It was fine. Not particularly memorable. Our server was old school. A bit of a character, which we liked. I cannot say I'd rush back but we enjoyed our meal at Bartolinos.
Frequently Asked Questions About Bartolino's The Hill
Where is Bartolino's The Hill located?
Bartolino's The Hill is located at 2103 Sulphur Avenue in St. Louis, Missouri, within the Drury Inn & Suites St. Louis Forest Park.
What type of cuisine does Bartolino's The Hill serve?
Bartolino's The Hill serves authentic Italian cuisine, reflecting the rich traditions of St. Louis's Italian neighborhood, The Hill.
What are the operating hours of Bartolino's The Hill?
Bartolino's The Hill is open Monday through Thursday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, Friday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, Saturday from 4:00 PM to 10:00 PM, and Sunday from 4:00 PM to 9:00 PM.
Does Bartolino's The Hill offer takeaway or delivery services?
Yes, Bartolino's The Hill offers both in-store pickup and delivery services for customer convenience.
Can I make a reservation at Bartolino's The Hill?
Yes, Bartolino's The Hill accepts reservations, but they are not required.
What payment methods are accepted at Bartolino's The Hill?
Bartolino's accepts American Express, Cash, Discover, Mastercard, and Visa cards for payment.
Does Bartolino's The Hill have facilities for families and children?
Bartolino's welcomes families and offers a children's menu and high chairs, providing a family-friendly dining experience.
Is Bartolino's The Hill accessible for people with disabilities?
Yes, Bartolino's has wheelchair-accessible entrances, parking, seating, and restrooms to accommodate guests with disabilities.
What nearby hotels can visitors to Bartolino's The Hill consider for accommodation?
Nearby hotels include Drury Inn & Suites St. Louis Forest Park, Forest Park Hotel, Holiday Inn St. Louis - Forest Park, and Red Roof PLUS+ St. Louis - Forest Park/Hampton Ave, offering convenient stays for restaurant visitors.
Are there convenient gas stations or convenience stores near Bartolino's The Hill?
Yes, Circle K, Shell, and QuikTrip are nearby providing convenient options for fuel and quick purchases before or after dining.
What attractions are close to Bartolino's The Hill for visitors to explore?
Picnic Island Forest Park is a nearby park and attraction visitors might enjoy visiting before or after their meal at Bartolino's The Hill.