We feature 32 flavors of homemade ice cream made in small batches in our Chincoteague Island kitchen. We source local fruit and rotate flavors seasonally. We also make our own waffle cones.
Customers consistently praised the ice cream for its rich, creamy texture and unique flavors, often describing it as the best they've ever had.
Customer Service
While many reviews highlighted friendly and helpful staff, there were some complaints about inconsistent service, particularly during busy times.
Variety and Options
The shop offers a wide variety of flavors, including vegan options, and allows customers to sample before purchasing, which is appreciated by many.
Atmosphere
The shop has a charming atmosphere with outdoor seating, although some customers noted it can get crowded and lacks indoor seating.
Pricing Concerns
A few customers expressed dissatisfaction with rising prices and perceived reductions in portion sizes, impacting their overall value perception.
MB
Matthew Borkoski
Jan 3, 2026
5.0
Best cream and service in the area
AH
Amy H
Dec 18, 2025
5.0
Awesome ice-cream, fair prices and friendly service.
CL
Calvin Lowe
Nov 5, 2025
5.0
Some of the best ice cream you can get. We live nearby and it doesn't matter what time of year you go, the staff is always super helpful and friendly. Whether you're getting a shake, ice cream cone or a cake, I will always recommend Island Creamery to anyone that visits. We have been here so much and can't even think about going anywhere else for ice cream. As long as we live here, this is our go-to.
MB
Marilou Bray
Oct 27, 2025
5.0
The very best!!!
JC
Joy Campbell
Oct 27, 2025
5.0
Delicious! And the service was friendly and very helpful. One of our top rated ice cream shops ever!
What types of ice cream does Island Creamery offer?
Island Creamery features 32 flavors of homemade ice cream made in small batches, using locally sourced fruit and rotating flavors seasonally.
Where is Island Creamery located?
Island Creamery is located at 120 N. Main St, Berlin, MD 21811, USA.
What are the operating hours of Island Creamery?
Island Creamery is open daily from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM.
What is the dress code at Island Creamery?
The attire at Island Creamery is casual.
Does Island Creamery accept credit cards and which ones?
Yes, Island Creamery accepts American Express, Discover, MasterCard, Visa, and also accepts cash payments.
Is Island Creamery accessible for customers with disabilities?
Yes, Island Creamery has wheelchair accessible entrances and free wheelchair accessible parking.
Does Island Creamery offer takeout or delivery services?
Island Creamery offers takeout service but does not provide delivery.
Can families with children visit Island Creamery comfortably?
Yes, Island Creamery welcomes children and provides a family-friendly environment.
What nearby ice cream shops can customers visit along with Island Creamery?
Nearby, customers can visit Yates on Mane, another ice cream shop and smoothie bar, offering additional treats and variety.
What attractions are near Island Creamery that visitors might enjoy?
Visitors to Island Creamery can explore Historic Downtown Berlin, known for its landmark and historical buildings, perfect for a scenic walk before or after enjoying ice cream.
Are there nearby places for shopping and dining near Island Creamery?
Yes, nearby options include Downtown Video for shopping and American cuisine, the Sterling Tavern for American dining, and the Maryland Wine Bar for a wine experience.