Long John Silver's

3.6
572 reviews
Seacret Society

About

Fast Food RestaurantSeafood RestaurantTake Out RestaurantChicken Restaurant
Real seafood should be sourced from real sea-places, like, you know, oceans. So that's exactly where we source our wild-caught Alaska pollock, wild-caught Alaska salmon, and wild-caught north Pacific cod. We’re no one trick sea pony.

Details

  • Dine-inAvailable
  • DeliveryAvailable
  • TakeoutAvailable
  • Credit cardAvailable

Location

Long John Silver's
2000 Burton Lane, Martinsville, IN
46151, United States

Hours

Reviews

3.6
572 reviews
5 stars
210
4 stars
132
3 stars
94
2 stars
41
1 star
95

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Food Quality

Mixed reviews on food quality; some praised freshness while others reported overcooked or undercooked items.

Cleanliness

Significant concerns about cleanliness, particularly in restrooms and dining areas, with many customers noting dirty conditions.

Service Speed

Service speed varied; some customers experienced quick service while others faced long waits.

Staff Attitude

Staff friendliness received mixed feedback; some praised the staff while others reported rudeness and impatience.

Value for Money

Customers expressed concerns about portion sizes and pricing, feeling that the food was overpriced for the quality received.
  • CL
    Cindy Lunsford
    Nov 11, 2025
    1.0
    My husband and I are lunch there last week. Within an hour I got sick with intestinal issues. Layer that evening my husband had the same problem I had. When the food was served I told my husband that the fries and hush puppies smelled weird. I ate 2 fries and couldn't eat aby more due to the smell and taste. I don't know if the products were bad or the oil they used for frying was bad but something was wrong. In addition every ketchup bottle they had was empty to the point that you could barely squeeze any ketchup out. When we requested more ketchup we were given another mostly empty bottle. I would've been embarrassed to do that to a customer. Something is definitely wrong at this Long John Silvers location.
  • DJ
    Di Johnson
    Oct 31, 2025
    1.0
    Horrible experience. I'm vertically challenged yet the kiosks were too low for me, thus hard to use. My companion and her father also had trouble using it. The lead, Kevin, sent another customer away from the register, refusing his order. That customer left. After my order was placed, the kiosk advised to request the receipt at the register. My fish came up, with zero crumbs. When I asked for some, a red haired girl quietly added a small basket. That was fine. My companion asked if crumbs no longer come with meals. Kevin stated you get two scoops, that's the policy. Fine. We went to sit down to eat. I noticed we hadn't gotten receipts, to do surveys for the free fish and side with purchase of drink. Went to the register to ask. Kevin stated no receipts are given. When I pointed out the kiosk indicated they could be had at the register, Kevin doubled down that no receipts were available. I saw my friend's receipt still on the register, so reached out and took it. Kevin shouted at me, swatted ay my hand, hitting his on the counter. He then charged out, ordering all three of us out, demanding we leave. He accused my friend of being rude, aggressive, and me of hitting him while I took the receipt. I'm sixty-two years old, five three in heels. Kevin is maybe thirties, a good ten to twelve inches taller and out weighs me by a hundred pounds. I would never try to hit anyone who looks like an old school linebacker, much less a restaurant worker, however obstreperous. After shouting at us for some time, and denying any responsibility for ensuring customer satisfaction, Kevin stated he would call his manager on us, then disappeared in the back. He came out a few minutes later and apologized for being aggressive and shouting. 0/10 will NOT visit that Long John Silver's ever again. Imagine, he chased off customer number four, shouted down customers one, two and three.
  • EH
    Edith House
    Oct 13, 2025
    3.0
    Don't like their French fries...kinda soft and greasy. Like their chicken, fish and clams and green beans. Would give higher rate if they had better fries.
  • CF
    Chris Faulds
    Oct 8, 2025
    4.0
    My wife and I had a serious craving for beer battered fish and chips. We were in a hurry and hadn't had Long John Silver's in a very long time. We thought, why not?!?! We stopped here and the staff was friendly and fast. We satisfied our craving and realized we should not wait so long for a return trip.
  • AA
    AMP
    Oct 5, 2025
    5.0
    Super busy but good food. Bought a bottle of malt vinegar to take home :)

Frequently Asked Questions About Long John Silver's

Can I order online and pickup in store?

Yes! Order online and pickup in store at participating Long John Silver's restaurants. Find your local LJS here: https://www.ljsilvers.com/locations

Can I see a menu?

You can see a menu here: https://www.ljsilvers.com/menu/