Business Details
About
Pizza RestaurantItalian RestaurantTake Out Restaurant
Family owned and operated, your family has been gathering around the table to enjoy our award winning stuffed pizza since 1972. We appreciate & thank you for loving our stuffed for over 50 years!! That's-some-sweet-sauce!!
Last order taken 30 minutes before closing!
Details
- DinnerAvailable
- Welcomes familiesAvailable
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.3
431 reviews
5 stars
305
4 stars
45
3 stars
24
2 stars
14
1 star
43
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Pizza Quality
Customers generally praise the pizza for its unique sweet sauce and quality ingredients, though some have noted inconsistencies in taste and preparation.
Customer Service
Feedback on customer service is mixed; while some customers appreciate the friendly staff, others report rude interactions and issues with order accuracy.
Pricing
Many reviews mention that the prices are on the higher side, which some customers feel is justified by the quality, while others find it excessive.
Order Issues
Several customers have experienced problems with their orders, including missing toppings and incorrect preparation, leading to dissatisfaction.
- MFMarco Falzone2 days ago3.0I’ve ordered a Family Size thin crust from two different locations recently and it seems like both were Large instead of Family size. I would hate for this to be the case if the price is going to be the same. I’ve been coming here for decades.
- RWrosa woollumsJan 3, 20265.0Great pizza as always! Also a favorite spot of my dear Friend. Dinner was perfect.
- KFKara FociaDec 28, 20253.0Fried cauliflower had no flavor. We asked for thin crust crispy pizza and it was like barely cooked dough. We usually love this place. Tonight they were not up to par.
- NONerdy OneDec 25, 20252.0I stumbled upon this place on accident trying to get around a freight train. I use to love sweet sauce pizza from pizzahut 15 years ago. So I thought what the heck majority of the reviews says it's really sweet. I enjoy sweet things so it shouldn't be a problem. WRONG. When I received the pizza hot and fresh it was very very sweet. The sweetness overpowered any other taste. It wasn't like a sweet taste like candy. It was like a sweet taste of to much sugar and now it taste bad with a after taste. I struggled to eat this pizza but I paid for it so I was forcing it down my throat. I ordered a small sasuage which came out to $17 which is expensive for the tiny pizza i received. I did end up having left overs which I threw into the air fryer the next day. On the leftovers I added red pepper flakes to offset the sweetness and to my surprise the 2nd day leftover tasted okay and the sweetness was gone on the leftovers so im giving them 2 stars because the leftovers was decent tasting. Only problem is i buy pizza for the fresh out the oven taste and not 2nd day left over out the fridge taste. Fast forward to a few days later I tried another pizza spot with sweet sauce and I got a medium sasuage it was $17 for the medium at another pizza spot. So Arrenello is expensive for the size you recieve and sweet tasting sauce. Everyone has different taste buds so i wish Arrenello best of luck in the future. I don't believe i will be returning to them, but others will and that is good as they have their place in the pizza world.
- AAAzreilNov 30, 20255.0Their pizza is always good. I've been coming here for over 5 years and the sweet sauce has not changed. Great Customer Service. Our family thin crust pizza are about $30-$35
Frequently Asked Questions About Arrenello's Pizza
What is the history of Arrenello's Pizza?
Arrenello's Pizza is a family owned and operated business serving award-winning stuffed pizza since 1972, with over 50 years of tradition.
Where is Arrenello's Pizza located?
Arrenello's Pizza is located at 2556 45th Street, Highland, Indiana, 46322, USA.
What are the operating hours of Arrenello's Pizza?
Arrenello's Pizza is open Monday, Wednesday, Thursday, and Sunday from 4:00 PM to 8:30 PM; Friday and Saturday from 4:00 PM to 9:30 PM; it is closed on Tuesdays. Last orders are taken 30 minutes before closing.
What types of payment does Arrenello's Pizza accept?
Arrenello's Pizza accepts American Express, Android Pay, Apple Pay, Cash, Discover, MasterCard, Samsung Pay, and Visa.
Does Arrenello's Pizza serve dinner and welcome families?
Yes, Arrenello's Pizza serves dinner and warmly welcomes families.
How can I contact Arrenello's Pizza for inquiries or orders?
You can contact Arrenello's Pizza by phone at +1 219-924-2525 or via email at krmatokar@gmail.com.
Where can I view the menu for Arrenello's Pizza?
The menu for Arrenello's Pizza can be viewed online at https://www.arrenellos.com/our-menu.
What nearby family-friendly dining options are close to Arrenello's Pizza?
Nearby family-friendly dining options include K's Restaurant, Krazy Hog BBQ, Mia's Cafe, Chole's Mexican Restaurant, and Dion's Breakfast Cafe, offering a variety of cuisines for you to enjoy before or after your visit.
Are there nearby services around Arrenello's Pizza for shopping and personal care?
Yes, near Arrenello's Pizza you'll find places like R.O.K Island Clothing, Queen's Beauty Supply & Wigs, Charlene's Hair Studio, and Rick's Clip Joint for clothing and beauty needs.
What educational and community facilities are located close to Arrenello's Pizza?
Nearby educational and community facilities include Brookwood Middle School, Brookwood Junior High School, Brookwood School District 167, Little Scholars Child Development Center, and Glenwood Fire Department Station 1.