Many customers praised the pizza for its delicious taste and quality, particularly the thin crust and fresh ingredients, while some expressed disappointment with specific items like the spaghetti and certain pizzas.
Customer Service
The owner and staff received numerous compliments for their friendliness and helpfulness, although there were also reports of poor customer service experiences.
Delivery Issues
Several reviews highlighted issues with delivery times and order accuracy, with some customers experiencing significant delays and incorrect orders.
Pricing Concerns
Customers noted that prices have increased significantly, leading to mixed feelings about the value for money, especially regarding certain menu items.
FW
Faith Whitwell
4 days ago
5.0
The pizza was delicious as usual, and the cream of chicken with rice soup never disappoints. ( it’s my favorite soup)
MB
Melanie Boushley
Dec 31, 2025
5.0
My fiancé and I recently moved to Genoa from closer to Chicago two years ago and we couldn’t find a good pizza place until we found Italian Dreams. We were so happy they delivered to Genoa and their pizza tastes like Chicago pizza to us! Super good, always hot, and always on time.
SS
Shanyn
Dec 29, 2025
5.0
Pizza was amazing as always!! Highly recommend!!
RK
Roy Kim
Dec 23, 2025
5.0
Solid go to local pizza joint. Nothing that blows you out of the water but good decent pizza and friendly service.
HP
Hope Di Piazza
Dec 14, 2025
5.0
On-line ordered pizza for delivery, it was really delicious!
Crust was nice and thin, baked just right, good sauce and toppings, lots of cheese (no need to order extra cheese imo)
Delivery was quick and pizza arrived hot. A bit expensive but worth it for the high-quality of the food and convenience of delivery.
Looking forward to trying some of the many other items on the menu!