Mixed reviews on food quality, with some praising the pizza and others expressing disappointment in specific dishes like lasagna and chicken parmesan.
Service Issues
Numerous complaints about rude staff and order mistakes, leading to customer dissatisfaction.
Consistency
While many customers appreciate the consistency in pizza preparation, others noted variations in crust thickness and ingredient quality.
Delivery Times
Delivery times are inconsistent, with some customers experiencing long waits and others receiving prompt service.
Overall Satisfaction
Despite some negative experiences, many customers still regard it as one of the best pizza places in the area, highlighting the flavor and value.
TM
TC M
3 days ago
5.0
Ordered here at 11:30 AM and ideally wanted to deliver it at 12:20 PM during a work break. They are very accommodating to allow that to happen and the delivery guy was there exactly at 12:20 maybe a few minutes earlier, therefore I tipped him well and that I did not have to wait
Pizza was very good. I enjoyed it. I live about 10 miles from the location but only work about a 2 miles from there. I will probably order here in the future to go pick it up.
I neglected to ask if they had tavern style and just re-ordered the regular style Pepperoni and sausage
Great sauce great amount of cheese. The dough was very good. It came piping hot on delivery.
Highly suggest supporting the locals in ordering from here. It was very good.
AS
Anton Seiler
Oct 23, 2025
5.0
Extra cheese with extra sauce!
RM
Reza T. Mousavian
Oct 22, 2025
1.0
I ordered Meat Lasagnia and Fried Chicken. 7 people were there with no Gloves. How is it possible for you guys to use your dirty hand and make food for people?! Lasagnia had maybe 40% sauce 20% cheese and at most 5% meat. Online price is also for nothing. Their real price is higher. It was my first and last time.
EZ
Eric Zumwalt
Oct 20, 2025
5.0
Kenny made the best pizza I have ever had !! Highly recommend this place!
KH
Kay Hafley
Aug 22, 2025
2.0
We did not realize nobody waits on you. You order your pizza, they do bring it to your table that’s it.
Pizza was not good too much sauce, not what I would call pan pizza at all either. Crust was not done enough.
It took an hour to get our pizza. Was not that busy.
Will not dine in again. Do not recommend.
Frequently Asked Questions About Pietro's Pizzeria
What type of food does Pietro's Pizzeria specialize in?
Pietro's Pizzeria specializes in pizza, dinners, sandwiches, and appetizers.
What are the opening hours of Pietro's Pizzeria?
Pietro's Pizzeria is open from 10:00 AM to 9:45 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and until 10:45 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.
Where is Pietro's Pizzeria located?
It is located at 5724 Elevator RD, Roscoe, IL 61073, US.
Which payment methods does Pietro's Pizzeria accept?
They accept American Express, Cash, Check, Discover, MasterCard, and Visa.
Does Pietro's Pizzeria have a bar or gaming options?
Yes, Pietro's Pizzeria offers a bar and gaming options including slot machines.
How can I contact Pietro's Pizzeria?
You can reach them by calling +1 815-623-2112.
Does Pietro's Pizzeria have an online presence?
Yes, their website is https://www.pietrospizzeria.net/ and they have a Facebook page at https://www.facebook.com/259108440870825.
What nearby places can I visit before or after dining at Pietro's Pizzeria?
Nearby places include the Stone Bridge Trail - Elevator Rd park for hiking, Louie's Tap House for additional dining or beer, and Pixel Paradise arcade and cafe for entertainment.
Are there any wellness or spa services near Pietro's Pizzeria?
Yes, nearby you can find Pam Aarli Massage, Elevated Ink Tattoo Studio, and Sweet Skin Waxing (femme beauty) for beauty and spa services.
Can I combine a visit to Pietro's Pizzeria with shopping or personal care nearby?
Certainly, you can visit Donovan & Company jewelry store or Meme's Upscale Consignment for shopping and also visit Hononegah Dental for dental care close by.