Nancy's Pizza Mokena

Reviews

• AH

  Allen Hughes

  Jan 5, 2026
  2.0
  I wanted to try this place based on a few recommendations, including one from my 1 year old son. Unfortunately, the experience fell short. The lady on the phone didn’t seem very enthusiastic ... just kind of blah. I picked up the order and didn’t check the pizza before leaving, which is on me. However, the pizza toppings were incorrect. The wings were prepared well and piping hot, so no complaints there. My sons are picky eaters and were disappointed, which led me to order Domino’s afterward. Nancy’s, if you’re reading this, I’m not sure how situations like this are handled, but feel free to reach out if you’d like.
• TD

  Tammy Dabbs

  Dec 31, 2025
  2.0
  Friendly staff but the pizza & the garlic bread is not the best. We were hoping for the old Nancy’s great pizza!!! This pizza crust is thin & the edges are thinner/flatter. The side doesn’t taste the same either. The garlic bread used to be two nice big pieces of bread now they’re cut into pieces with parsley & parm on them, not my liking. Very disappointed!!! I hate looking around for good pizza 😢
• FS

  Frank Schreiner

  Dec 20, 2025
  5.0
  Nancy's stuffed pizza is consistently good. Tasty sauce, crip crust never over done. Lots of cheese, great cheese pull. Sausage has plenty of flavor. Staff is friendly and the pizza is always on time. Nancy's stuffed pizza beats the other well known deep dish pizzas.
• BE

  Brandon Engel

  Nov 22, 2025
  5.0
  The GOAT of Chicago pizza anyone who says otherwise is wrong
• CR

  Cathy Roecker

  Nov 2, 2025
  1.0
  Ordered a pizza for delivery yesterday. Now I remember why I usually order from Nancy's in New Lenox. The pizza was over cooked, dry, and pretty much horrible. It angers me when you pay for something and it sucks.