Dewey’s Pizza is an upscale casual, gourmet pizza concept with 27 locations throughout the Midwest. We’ve been in business for over two decades and are known for our creative pizza and salad combinations and local craft beer. We pride ourselves on warm service set to our custom playlist to take your pizza experience to a new level. We currently have locations in Cincinnati, Columbus, Cleveland, Dayton, Akron, Kansas City and St. Louis.
Customers consistently praised the pizza for its unique flavors, quality ingredients, and excellent crust.
Service
The staff received high marks for being friendly, attentive, and professional, contributing to a positive dining experience.
Atmosphere
The restaurant has a lively atmosphere, though some found it a bit noisy when busy.
Pricing
While many felt the food was worth the price, some noted that it can be on the pricier side.
Consistency
There were mixed reviews regarding consistency in food quality, with some customers experiencing variations in their orders.
QB
Quenton Bartony
4 days ago
4.0
The pizza was good. We tried the classic red and white. They could use a bit more cheese, and the cheese wasn't all the way to the crust on the red. They also probably would have been better fresh/dine-in than after a 30-minute drive home. Pizza's were not on time and I had to wait about 5 mintutes with kids waiting in the car. Slightly overpriced for a cheese only pizza.
AA
AvgJoe
Dec 29, 2025
5.0
Rolling into downtown Edwardsville on a quiet Monday during Christmas break felt a bit like showing up to a party after everyone already went home. But fear not — because Dewey’s Pizza was the one house on the block still blasting good vibes and serving cold beer.
We walked in expecting “Monday energy,” but instead were greeted like long‑lost friends who finally decided to stop ghosting them. No wait, no fuss, just instant seating and a staff so genuinely cheerful I briefly wondered if they were running on Yuengling instead of coffee.
Speaking of Yuengling — we ordered a round, and let me tell you, it hit harder than a plot twist in a soap opera. Perfectly cold, perfectly refreshing, perfectly yes please, another.
Then came the star of the evening: the Dr. Dre pizza. And no, it didn’t drop a beat — it dropped a masterpiece. Fresh ingredients, perfectly balanced flavors, and a crust that honestly deserves its own fan club. Light and fluffy, but with just enough crunch to remind you it’s not messing around. This crust had personality. This crust had swagger. This crust said, “I’m a serious pizza, respect me.”
One of the most interesting parts? Their tag‑team service style. Every time we looked up, a new friendly face appeared — like Pokémon, but instead of battling, they brought beer and checked on our happiness levels. I don’t think we saw the same server twice, but every single one of them was on point.
Great pizza. Great beer. Great atmosphere. And a staff so good they could probably run a small country.
Dewey’s, you were the unexpected jackpot of our Monday night.
#GOSIUE
NM
Noelle Morrese
Dec 19, 2025
5.0
Pizza like no other!
GF
Gabriel F.
Dec 14, 2025
5.0
Pizzatime
LY
Lauren Yoder
Oct 24, 2025
5.0
Pizza was great. The gluten free crust was amazing. Clean restaurant and service was awesome! Love the 1/2 and 1/2 option!!!