Antonella's Pizzeria Fairbanks

4.6
834 reviews

About

Italian Restaurant

Details

  • DeliveryAvailable
  • TakeoutAvailable
  • Curbside pickupAvailable

Location

Antonella's Pizzeria Fairbanks
360 W Fairbanks Ave, Winter Park, FL
32789, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.6
834 reviews
5 stars
663
4 stars
84
3 stars
23
2 stars
18
1 star
46

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Food Quality

Many customers praised the pizza for its delicious taste and authentic New York style, while others noted a decline in quality and freshness since the change in ownership.

Service

The staff received mixed reviews; some customers highlighted friendly and attentive service, while others reported unprofessional behavior and issues with order accuracy.

Cleanliness

Several reviews raised concerns about cleanliness, including unsanitary conditions and questionable food handling practices.

Customer Experience

While many enjoyed their dining experience, there were notable complaints about order fulfillment issues and inconsistent food quality.
  • ND
    Naomi Delgado
    3 days ago
    5.0
    This is the absolute BEST Italian restaurant we have ever been too. (And we have been to quite a few!) - The cooking was AMAZING but best of all our server, Nick, was truly remarkable!! Once we expressed how happy and amazing the food was he even brought the chef out and we were able to meet and thank him. They truly made us feel as if we were part of the family. If you want an authentic experience with a loving team, go to Antonella’s. We will definitely be back next Sunday. ❤️ I cannot express enough how wonderful of an experience we had. Side note: our kids had pizza and me and my husband had the pastas. EVERYTHING was delicious. HIGHLY RECOMMEND! Thank you Nick and team for being incredible!
  • LD
    Lucas Donlon
    3 days ago
    5.0
    They are back! The original taste of Antonella’s is finally back! It was great to see Emily and crew tonight. Oh how I have missed the pizza and knots!
  • EO
    E O
    4 days ago
    1.0
    I ordered a buffalo chicken pie. It was disgusting and gave me food poisoning it came with a pound of onions on it. Cheese was not melted. It was horrible. My family all got sick from it.
  • NN
    NRL
    Jan 3, 2026
    5.0
    Excelente lugar para comer, la mejor atención y el mejor sabor, comida artesanal, fresca y deliciosa. Recomendado 100% ***** Excellent!!!! the best attention, taste, artisanal, fresh and delicious food. Recommended 100%
  • KK
    Kyle
    Jan 2, 2026
    5.0
    First time eating here on 12/31/25, Kekes across the street recommend this place. Well it didn’t disappoint! Got two slices of pizza with cheese only and a regular salad. Pizza tasted great, a little oily but lots of flavor! Salad was also good and fresh. Emily was our server, loved her positive attitude and smile. She greeted me and my friend when we walked in. Asked how we were doing and got our food in less than 10 minutes. Will come again! Thank you Emily for the positive experience! A++