Customers consistently praised the food for being authentic, fresh, and delicious, with many highlighting specific dishes like moussaka, lentil soup, and baklava.
Service Experience
While many reviews noted friendly and attentive service, there were also complaints about rude interactions and rushed service during busy times.
Atmosphere
The restaurant is described as cozy and charming, creating a welcoming environment that feels like a taste of Greece.
Reservation Policy
Several customers emphasized the importance of making reservations due to the restaurant's small size and popularity, with some expressing frustration over being turned away without one.
HL
Helena Lockwood
Dec 31, 2025
5.0
What a cozy atmosphere! Beautifuly decorated, beautiful Greek music playing. The food was absolutely delicious! I would go back any time.
DS
Debbie Sullivan
Dec 30, 2025
5.0
Four of us paid our first visit (and definitely not the last!) to Stella's earlier this month. We loved the atmosphere, music, terrific food, and wonderful service. The menu is incredible, prices are very good value for what we received, and all dishes were exemplary. We were only sorry that we had no room for any of the appealing desserts. We will definitely return soon! Tip: this is a small restaurant so be sure to make a reservation by following the link on Stella's website. Yelp handles the reservations and texts reminders.
DB
Dayle Berke
Dec 27, 2025
5.0
This spot was amazing! If you are looking for authentic Greek cuisine then this 100% the place you need to go. The owners Pietro and Stella are absolutely wonderful and took the time to tell us all about their food, family, and history. We can't wait to come back and are already planning our next visit.
TF
Terra Fina
Dec 24, 2025
5.0
We love this cozy restaurant on the south side of Sarasota. It has the best Greek food in town, and wonderful music and friendly staff. The Christmas dinner menu was tasty this year washed down with nectar and baklava. Salud.
MF
Michael Fenichel
Dec 5, 2025
5.0
OK Google! My first restaurant review 'here'. Because.... I've raved and recommended word-of-mouth and on some foodie sites... Just curious... And the reviews I'm seeing here are spot-on, giving me little to add.
Thin-sliced: The appetizers, soups, salads and entrées I've seen or had: all amazing. As others say, "home-made" (and if you hear the story, truly a labor of love and a lot of history).
Craving a decent moussaka, I found this little gem 2-3 years ago and return as often as I can, still loving the "Moussakas Politikos" (another story to ask about), both the signature soups (lentil & lemon), and various spreads, sides, and desserts. All wonderful.
Long "retired" from ongoing restaurant reviews, I'm still an avid eater, and between the northeast and southeast, have a short list of favorites in New York and Sarasota mostly, the places where this restaurant owner has had restaurants over many years and adventures.
Stella's is unpretentious but charming, lights twinkling everywhere, art from Greece, fantastic music, devoted owner & chef.
I recommend it to friends, so why not 'here'? It's a small place, so don't all go at once! Do call, and reserve even, as it can fill up.
Frequently Asked Questions About Stella's Greek Cuisine
What are the operating hours of Stella's Greek Cuisine?
Stella's Greek Cuisine is open from 4:30 PM to 9:00 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday. On Friday and Saturday, it operates from 5:00 PM to 9:30 PM.
Does Stella's Greek Cuisine offer delivery and pickup services?
Yes, the restaurant offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.
Where is Stella's Greek Cuisine located?
It is located at 4783 Swift Rd, Sarasota, FL 34231, USA.
How can I view the menu or place an order for Stella's Greek Cuisine?
You can view the menu and place orders online at https://stellasgreekcuisine.com/menu.
What type of cuisine does Stella's Greek Cuisine serve?
Stella's Greek Cuisine offers Greek and Mediterranean food, including health-conscious and vegetarian options.
What is the price range at Stella's Greek Cuisine?
The restaurant falls into the mid-range or 'TWO' price category.
Can I pick up my order directly from Stella's Greek Cuisine?
Yes, in-store pickup is available during operating hours.
Are there any convenient stores nearby if I need to grab snacks or gas before or after dining?
Yes, there is a 7-Eleven nearby that provides convenience store items, gas station services, and a liquor store.
Where can I find a nail salon or beauty spa near Stella's Greek Cuisine?
Oriental Nails by Kim, a nail and beauty salon, is nearby, offering services you can visit before or after your meal.
Are there other restaurants close to Stella's Greek Cuisine if I want to explore more dining options?
Yes, Bangkok Restaurant is a nearby Thai and Asian restaurant, and European Restaurant and Deli offers delicatessen and grocery options close by.