Customers consistently praised the pizza for being delicious, hot, and well-prepared, with many considering it the best in town.
Customer Service
While many reviews highlighted friendly and attentive service, there were some complaints about inconsistent service and rude staff experiences.
Value for Money
Customers appreciated the fair pricing, discounts, and rewards program, often mentioning the good deals available.
Delivery Experience
Delivery was frequently noted as fast and reliable, with many customers expressing satisfaction with the promptness and quality of their orders.
BW
Bryce Woods
6 days ago
1.0
Won't deliver a pizza to me only 3.5 miles away because I'm "out of their zone". Honestly a joke for a pizza place to call that out of their zone.
MB
Michelle Barber
Jan 4, 2026
5.0
Pizza is always delivered timely and hot and delicious. My go to pizza place is Five Star!
IM
Isabella Molina
Jan 3, 2026
5.0
Always amazing & friendly service! Their pepperoni rolls are to die for and they have the best deals
MR
Manatee County Reviews
Dec 26, 2025
5.0
The food here is amazing they never give me any issues the customer service is always amazing the pizza and the wings here are awesome! They are always crispy and flavorful!
MK
Monika Kent
Dec 16, 2025
5.0
They are open later than most places here, seems everything closes at sun down! Food is always good and meets my expectations, haven’t had a negative experience here to date.
Frequently Asked Questions About Five Star Pizza - Bradenton
What types of services does Five Star Pizza - Bradenton offer?
Five Star Pizza - Bradenton offers in-store pickup and delivery services for their pizza, wings, sides, and desserts.
What are the operating hours of Five Star Pizza - Bradenton?
Five Star Pizza - Bradenton is open from 11:00 AM to 1:00 AM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and until 2:00 AM on Fridays and Saturdays.
Does Five Star Pizza - Bradenton serve late-night food?
Yes, Five Star Pizza - Bradenton serves late-night food, staying open until 1:00 AM on most nights and 2:00 AM on weekends.
Can customers dine in at Five Star Pizza - Bradenton?
Yes, customers can dine in as Five Star Pizza - Bradenton offers seating, counter service, and is family-friendly.
Does Five Star Pizza - Bradenton have an online ordering option?
Yes, customers can place orders online via their order URL at https://secure.microworks.com/FiveStar/LandingPage.
What types of food and drink does Five Star Pizza - Bradenton serve?
They serve pizza, specialty pizzas, wings, garlic rolls, sides, desserts, and also offer beer and wine.
How can I contact Five Star Pizza - Bradenton for orders or inquiries?
You can call Five Star Pizza - Bradenton at +1 941-251-4491.
Is there a popular financial service nearby that customers might visit before or after dining?
Yes, Edward Jones - Financial Advisor offices of John E Hornberger and James W Campbell Jr are nearby and accessible for those handling financial matters before or after their meal.
What entertainment venues are near Five Star Pizza - Bradenton that customers might enjoy?
Nearby entertainment includes the Howard Studio Theatre, SCF Neel Performing Arts Center, and Neel Auditorium, suitable for visiting before or after dining.
Are there any sports or recreational facilities near Five Star Pizza - Bradenton?
Yes, customers can visit the SCF Softball Complex, Robert C. Wynn Baseball Field, Hal Chasey Gymnasium, or Bayshore Village Condominium One Association gym for sports and recreation.