Business Details
About
Italian Restaurant
Details
- DeliveryAvailable
- TakeoutAvailable
- Curbside pickupAvailable
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.6
1,325 reviews
5 stars
1,027
4 stars
197
3 stars
52
2 stars
20
1 star
29
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Customers consistently praised the food for being delicious, fresh, and authentic, particularly highlighting the pizza and Italian dishes.
Service
The service received high marks for being attentive, friendly, and accommodating, with several customers mentioning specific staff members who enhanced their experience.
Atmosphere
Many reviews noted the pleasant atmosphere of the restaurant, describing it as cozy and inviting, although a few mentioned issues with temperature.
Value
Customers appreciated the generous portion sizes and reasonable prices, often mentioning the good value of the buffet options.
- KGKevin Gould3 days ago5.0Our to-go order was ready early and was delicious as usual!
- JGJohn & Carolle GrahamJan 4, 20264.0We just left this place. We were told when we sat down that we would get garlic rolls. We got our salad (very good). Then got our bbq chicken pizza (okay). We asked about getting rolls 3 different times & never got them. The guys did not even ask us about them when we paid our bill or got up to leave. Wow,
- SCShayene CardosoDec 27, 20255.0An Italian restaurant with authentic, beautifully executed cuisine. The standout dish is the garlic bread, simply impeccable: crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, and incredibly aromatic, truly unforgettable. The pizza dough is light and perfectly baked, the calzone impresses with its balance of flavors, and the cannoli rounds out the experience with elegance. The service was warm and attentive, with a knowledgeable team ready to guide and answer any questions, which further elevates the dining experience. 😉
- KMKerri MDec 25, 20255.0Love this place!!! One of the few places we feel comfortable eating at and always accommodating to my dietary needs. Great food and fantastic service!
- VSVerna SaxonDec 8, 20255.0This was our first time but not our last! The service here is top-notch!! Even when our waiter was waiting on other tables there were other servers checking our drinks and filling them for us. They even removed plates we were finished with. When it comes to top-notch Aiden our waiter gets the "prize"! Some things food wise we had questions about and he gave good answers! Even laughing with us when we made comments about being "such hard to get along with eaters"( our male friend with us 3 ladies). We loved the way he announced exactly what each one of us was getting served and "hope you enjoy it"! Not once but for each one of us!! I'm telling you IF I still managed convenience stores I would be trying to steal him away! Hopefully you have some way of showing him appreciation because he deserves to be applauded!! It was a great experience overall because of the atmosphere! Just the soft sounds of people enjoying being there and no loud tvs playing!! As I said at the beginning of this review we're planning on coming back and bringing other friends with us!
Frequently Asked Questions About New York Pizza Plus
What are the regular business hours for New York Pizza Plus?
New York Pizza Plus is open from 10:00 AM to 8:30 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and from 10:00 AM to 9:30 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.
Does New York Pizza Plus offer delivery and pickup services?
Yes, New York Pizza Plus offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.
Are there any holidays when New York Pizza Plus is closed?
Yes, New York Pizza Plus is closed on Christmas Day and New Year's Day each year.
Where is New York Pizza Plus located?
New York Pizza Plus is located at 15202 NW 147 Dr #100, Alachua, FL 32615, USA.
Where can I view the menu for New York Pizza Plus?
You can view the menu for New York Pizza Plus online at https://newyorkpizzaplusfl.com/menu.
What types of cuisine does New York Pizza Plus serve?
New York Pizza Plus serves Italian cuisine, including pizza, sandwiches, pasta, salads, vegetarian and gluten-free options, desserts, and offers catering services.
What nearby places can help me find New York Pizza Plus?
Nearby landmarks include Caution Horses (an auto body shop), Number One Nail & Spa, and Elite Wellness & Laboratory Service, which can help you locate New York Pizza Plus in Alachua.
Are there any nearby fitness centers close to New York Pizza Plus?
Yes, Anytime Fitness, a gym and sports recreation venue, is located nearby and can be convenient if you want to combine dining with a workout.
Can I visit a beauty salon near New York Pizza Plus?
Yes, Number One Nail & Spa and Salon Boutique are nearby beauty salons where you can get spa and grooming services before or after dining.
Where can I find medical or health-related services near New York Pizza Plus?
Nearby medical-related services include Elite Wellness & Laboratory Service, Carter Healthcare (Education Center), LabCorp, and Alachua Family Dentistry, providing a range of diagnostic and healthcare options.