Bruegger’s bakes up authentic New York style bagels every morning, ready to be topped with our signature made-in-Vermont cream cheese or perfect for a variety of breakfast and deli sandwiches alongside tasty sides of hashbrowns, muffins, sweets, and custom blends of hot and iced coffee. Breakfast & lunch catering is available by ordering online. In a hurry? Order Ahead using the Bruegger’s mobile app.
Customers frequently praised the bagels for being fresh, flavorful, and well-prepared, with some describing them as the best they've ever had.
Service Consistency
While many reviews highlighted friendly and efficient staff, there were notable complaints about inconsistent service and rude interactions.
Menu Issues
Several customers reported issues with menu items being unavailable or not meeting expectations, particularly regarding portion sizes and quality.
Atmosphere and Cleanliness
The atmosphere was generally described as pleasant, but some customers expressed concerns about cleanliness and the lack of indoor dining options.
CS
Cleveland Solomon
4 days ago
1.0
Please do not purchase gift cards because we purchase a gift card and only used it once, their system been down for a month, I was given one sandwich once at no charge and return to order and system was down again. I was told that I have to pay for sandwich even though my card still have money. It appears the upper management has no solution for this issue when your purchase gift card and can not use it. Save your self the headache and do not purchase gift cards if is not working and refuse to refund money. Several calls were made to district manager with no answering service or voicemail indicating whom you have reach. Good bagel but bad upper management at the New Haven CT store. I am not sure if the investors would want their investments being manage poorly which in turn leads to a bad investment because of poor management. I left with out breast sandwich even letting the Supervisor guy know I was hungry and is a regular customer. In these situation you have to support the local coffee and sandwich shops whom are invested in the community to build good relationship with their customers and resolve issues in a timely manner especially when it comes to food I would ASAP.
BM
Barbara Mohedano
Dec 14, 2025
5.0
I love the jalapeño bagel! 🥯😻
AC
Amber Caggiano
Nov 30, 2025
5.0
This is my favorite place to go! These people know and adore their regulars. They always got you taken care of! Wouldn't wanna go anywhere else!
KM
Kevin Martinez
Nov 20, 2025
5.0
Loved it
SP
Stephen Polauf
Nov 18, 2025
4.0
Great selection of bagels and condiments. I have yet to find a better shop for bagels and coffee. They are also outstanding at coffee. The caramel iced latte is one of the best around. Sometimes, service can be inconsistent, and menu items seem to vanish. Infrequent enough to warrant a single-star demerit.
Frequently Asked Questions About Bruegger's Bagels
What type of food does Bruegger's Bagels specialize in?
Bruegger's Bagels specializes in authentic New York style bagels, gourmet topped bagels, and breakfast and deli sandwiches made with Vermont cream cheese.
What are the operating hours of Bruegger's Bagels at 1 Whitney Avenue, New Haven?
The store is open every day from 6:00 AM to 2:00 PM.
Does Bruegger's Bagels offer catering services?
Yes, Bruegger's Bagels offers both breakfast and lunch catering, which can be ordered online.
Can I order ahead or use a mobile app to order from Bruegger's Bagels?
Yes, you can order ahead using the Bruegger's mobile app available for Android and iOS.
What payment options are accepted at Bruegger's Bagels?
They accept American Express, Visa, MasterCard, Discover, cash, and mobile payments including Apple Pay, Android Pay, Samsung Pay, and contactless payments.
Does Bruegger's Bagels provide takeout and delivery options?
Yes, Bruegger's Bagels offers takeout, delivery, and in-store pickup options.
What nearby public places can help me find Bruegger's Bagels at 1 Whitney Avenue?
Sta Travel, a travel agency, and Mills & Cahill law firm are nearby and can serve as landmarks to locate Bruegger's Bagels.
Are there other dining options near Bruegger's Bagels?
Yes, nearby dining options include Bella Casa Vegana vegetarian restaurant, Costa Pizza Restaurant, and Lilly's Gourmet Pasta Express Italian restaurant.
Which nearby places can I visit for coffee or drinks near Bruegger's Bagels?
Willoughby's Coffee & Tea cafe and The Basement pub are close by if you'd like to enjoy coffee or drinks after your visit.
What are some nearby service-related businesses around Bruegger's Bagels?
Nearby services include Jo Bruno Hair salon, Ted's Cleaners laundromat, and Whitney Massage Therapy spa for beauty and wellness needs.